Solution to prevent herb/ore multiboxing from running the economy

Yep, single tapped nodes were an amazing time for botters.

Nobody is falling for this.

I still can’t see the issue.

The problem with your strategy is that people like me exist.

I wonder…

Is it possible that botters, perceiving legit multiboxers as having some impact on their activities, are behind many of these complaints about something Blizzard specifically states is allowed?

3 Likes

Why not make nodes individual to each player? If the nodes for everyone are on different locations then multiboxing would be pointless for gathering.

1 Like

Yes, calling people multicheaters should be a bannable offense.

Here’s the issue.

Bots are headless. Meaning if you give everyone a personal farm ala Warlords of Draenor Garrison someone will have the brilliant idea of firing up thousands of bots on their server farm to farm herbs.

Because bots are headless they can exist on an infinite number of shards operating independently of each other. It’s far and away the most damaging form of activity to the game economy.

Multiboxing is limited by the fact one person is controlling them all. This means one shard, 10 max. Anything more than that and their clear speed is gone.

We don’t want bots controlling the market. The way it is now dozens or hundreds of players are operating on different shards and some 1-2% of them are multiboxing. It’s seriously not the issue people think it is.

2 Likes

If they are smart (they arnt) they will make crafting materials soulbound in shadowlands, something that should have been done a decade ago.

That wouldn’t be smart.

1 Like

No, I hate it when they fix a 0.5% problem to the detriment of 99% of the other players.

Most people don’t multibox, and at least multiboxers are putting money into the game.

I also hate that the Bwonsomdi’s Bargain thing for M+ doesn’t show up for 10+ now, because I guess 0.5% of the population was abusing it, so we have to punish 99.5% of the rest of us.

3 Likes

As the guy that supplies our raids with cauldrons, I spend a couple of hours a week gathering herbs and I have noticed an increase on “hydra” players gathering as well. But it doesn’t really impact my ability to gather, as the node despawn mechanics doesn’t change if a single character or several interact with it. I actually thought it would drive down the herb market price but I honestly haven’t noticed that much of a change in the big name herbs either. So if they are flooding the market, it is a market that is still willing to pay top dollar for their herbs.

1 Like

Naj herbs can only be found in Naj and are included in everything.

Basically we’ll never see those drop to 8g like the others which I think was intended to control the supply of flasks to the market.

Multiboxers are an insignificant factor in that as you’ve observed. 0.1% * 10 is 1%…

1 Like

Yet another account advocating a change which will greatly benefit bots.

Where’s the botting forum where these threads are being organised? Perhaps some multiboxers would like invites to go there and yell “multicheaterfarmcapitalgoldistoppresssbots”.

I’ve been learning amazing new words from some of these boxing threads.

3 Likes

So the complaint is that the value of the mats is dropping because multi-boxing?

give me a break.

The people complaining are probably the same ones trying to buy up all the low priced mats and then relist at a much higher price.

I support multi-boxers flooding the market with mats.

and I support Saudi increasing production of crude to further drive down the price of oil.

QQ

That doesn’t take into account how fast it can be gathered. Mutliboxers can gather faster with many herbs concentrated on one node, than if it’s spread out over many nodes. Nodes per time is the same uni or multi boxing, so you end up with something like 80% of the herbs going to 10% of the players (the exact number is not known, but that gives the idea of what’s going on.)

Example:
uni-boxer:
-1 node per minute * 3 herbs per node = 3 herbs per minute

multi-boxer
-1 node per minute * 15 herbs per node = 15 herbs per minute

without multi-tap: uni boxer unaffected, multi-boxer gathers the same as a uni boxer.

Im starting to wonder now that youve said it.

1 Like

wish theyd come to my server. I like cheap mats so I dont have to drag myself across half of the game every day. :slight_smile:

SInce multiboxers are the only one that can gather quickly enough, they corner the market and jack up the price. Nazjatar is the only place for Zin, multiboxers swallow it up. Remove multi-tap, make more nodes, even the playing field.

1 Like

present a case to blizzard.
Doesnt ruin my game either way.
I either make a mint farming and selling mats…or I buy the mats cheap that someone else farmed, make crap and sell that crap and StiLL make my gold.

Not really sure how this is that hard for a few players in here.
If it aint making gold…do something else.

So which is it? In these threads we see people a) complaining about the prices being depressed by multiboxers so they can’t make any money and b) people like you complaining they are driving up prices. It can’t be both…so maybe you should all get together and decide which one is the real issue.