I agree that every class should be available to every race. I think they just need to differentiate the classes a bit to be more lore appropriate. Feels silly when every paladin still has angel wings for certain spell effects, for example.
What? We were all literally just following Saurfang last expansion to the gates of Ogrimmar. Legion has us working with characters that eventually became Horde(Nightborne/Highmountain taurens) and in WoD Thrall took our killing blow of Garrosh!
The saurfang narrative was “oopsie we messed up again because we’re dumb” which does not a compelling narrative make for heroic characters or people you like. Every expansion since MoP has been a celebration of alliance heroics.
Somehow you blame Alliance players for this, rather than Blizzard. We can make our requests, but Blizzard are the ones that implement them. Lest people forget, Alliance wanted High Elves that looked different from Blood Elves.
At this point they should just drop race/class restrictions altogether. Even stuff like Forsaken Paladins/Druids makes sense these days.
Blood Elves shouldn’t get Dark Ranger customizations, “to compensate.” They should get them because they make sense, and always did. Dark Ranger/San’layn options for Blood Elves are so ridiculously overdue, it’s like the High Elf wait all over again.
Maybe if the Horde wasnt made up of so many “morally gray” characters they wouldnt keep getting villain batted. In any case, at this point we have probably purged every last major antagonistic force in the Horde at this point.
Also, pretty sure both Mayla/Thalysra, both Horde characters now, were present in fairly favorable lights.
What about 2 expansions (WoD and Legion) of endless Daghar jokes or Little Rocky in BfA constantly going " Chumpyoun yae need ta be gathrin more azerite yae world be needn yae to heal her woonz"
So, Sylvanas was a genuinely interesting character per her WC3 writing. But the power scaling for every character got so ridiculous that the story stopped being focused on grounded, localized threats. And I think Sylvanas specifically got one of the worst depictions due to the genuine incompetence of Afraisabi who was fired for misconduct.
If anything her warcraft 3 writing was proof she was always going to be a sore spot for everyone. She was effectively a retread of Kerrigan and suffice to say alot of people have less then positive things to say about how that whole thing ended for Kerrigan.
What made her different from Kerrigan initially was that she was a character who could have carved out an existence for the fallen of lordaeron and intervened in local politics. A character who isn’t nice, per say, but isn’t genuinely evil.
But then they just kept leaning into her initial tragedy that she never got to heal from (until shadowlands) rather than letting her grow into her new state of undeath with allies and confidence. I just really wish they handled her differently, because undead with complex motivations are always interesting to me.
I know that the whole reason they made the night elves was that they wanted something different from tolkien elves for their original IP and did so successfully with them.
They made blood elves later because they wanted to do another unique spin on them.