Ziryus:
carry a shaman.
Also known as: not performing the role. If you have to be carried, you’re not pulling your weight (by definition) and thus you aren’t fulfilling your duties (by definition) and so calling you any kind of role is simply false.
Bonerover:
Okay, pro.
Quite pro. Check out my worst Resto parse:
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/prFbB8dgZQ24nfHG#fight=37&type=healing
Now check out how many people died:
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/prFbB8dgZQ24nfHG#fight=37&type=deaths
Now check out how low anyone got:
https://classic.warcraftlogs.com/reports/prFbB8dgZQ24nfHG#fight=37&type=resources
Funny how healing parses don’t mean jack squat.
There you go again. Making up your own rules to validate your poor play.
Keep giving those hunters crit and you’ll keep your spot.
…what poor play? What rules? Are you about to tell me that you’re a post-modernist? Just making up words as you go?
Fasc:
What rules?
A tank doesn’t have to do X Y and Z just to satisfy your requirements as a tank.
You’re making stuff up.
If X, Y, and Z are what a Tank needs to do in order to Tank the encounter in question… yes.
Otherwise no.
Did they clear the Karazhan in the video above?
Did the shaman follow the definition given by Blizzard on what tanks do?
Fasc:
What definition?
Per the Official Strategy Guide “A tank reduces incoming damage,”
That’s all.
Ah yes… the Official Strategy Guide of Bonerover…
So you don’t have a definition. Just say that next time.
Lummis, M., & Vanderlip, D. (2005). Group Roles. In World of warcraft: Official strategy guide. essay, Pearson Education.
But continue to make up your own definition. I like seeing you cling to some reason why you keep thinking you’re decent.
Bwahahaha…
Dude. You listed a BradyGames author.
You said:
BradyGames isn’t Blizzard.
You also didn’t provide a complete citation for anyone to verify. Again, you’re just stating the Official Strategy Guide according to Bonerover.
Yup. It has Blizzard seal on it. They paid someone else to write their book you know?
Just because a company subcontracts something, doesn’t mean it’s not theirs.
Did they name their office after the construction crews?
Fine enough. It’s still negative although I was a bit dramatic on the hate.
Not sure how pointing out that a shaman was getting carried means I hate shaman.
I would say the exact same thing if you showed a video of a warlock “tanking” kara.
2 Likes
So now I have layers of “Dude Trust Me” citations:
A BradyGames author is sanctioned by Blizzard
A supposed quote actually comes from from a supposed strategy guide
A supposed quote has no further information or details or context
A supposed quote was specifically sanctioned by Blizzard
I’ll give you a hint about the authenticity of BradyGames guides:
https://wowpedia.fandom.com/wiki/The_Light_Stands_Strong#cite_note-1
Making up your own rules again.
The Official Blizzard Guide says something yet you deny it. You live in denial.
I can’t deny what doesn’t exist.
Any of the information you’ve asserted is real.
I’m aware that BradyGames made an “official” strategy guide for WoW, just like they do for all sorts of other games. But what hasn’t been shown is anything actually connecting the existence of such a guide with anything you’ve said about the guide.
Keep up.
Making up your own rules again, 2nd.
The Official guide says something, yet you deny it to it’s face. Denial.
No. YOU say something. You haven’t shown anything other than yourself.
As per the Official Strategy Guide, Blizzard says that Fasc is correct and Bonerover is not.
See? You can’t deny me now. The Official Strategy Guide said so.