Its kinda amazing to me how many classic players think every raid boss should be on farm within the first day or week of release or otherwise its “retail”. I think this is the result of many of these players playing nothing but classic WoW over and over and OVER again for 20 years without any new content which has over time given them mush brain with the impression that Classic WoW is supposed to be very easy even though it never really was because anyone who played Classic WoW in 2004-2006 knows that BWL, AQ, and Naxx were not easy pushover raids for their day, far from it.
Now is Scarlet Enclave overtuned? I don’t know, maybe, but that’s a separate conversation from the fact that many classic players have long short-circuited over even a mild challenge. And the fact that Scarlet Enclave is likely the final raid of SOD makes this even weirder to me.