Ideally, San’layn would be their own race slot on the character creation screen. I’ve talked about it multiple times before, so I’ll try to do an abridged version as best as I can.
They’re different enough, both culturally and in terms of aesthetics, that it would work a lot better for them to be their own race as opposed to being slapped onto Blood Elves as a customization race. They’re capable of having their own racials, storylines, and racial hub to warrant being their own race as well.
Being a customization race is worrying for a number of reasons. Playable races in any form should have a storyline presence and be able to have their own identity. While this is possible, so far seeing what they’ve done with Wildhammers, who are just slapped onto Bronzebeard Dwarves, hasn’t given me a lot of confidence that any future customization races will get better treatment.
Speaking of, we have Sand Trolls in the Horde somehow without any explanation. The only Sand Troll tribes that exist hate the Horde, so it’s weird to see them just suddenly part of the Horde without any explanation. Are they part of any fo the existing Sand Troll tribes? A new tribe? Are they just Darkspear Trolls with a different skin tone? No idea! There was a potential talk of an explanation coming “soon,” but I don’t like the idea of just putting a race in and giving the explanation later. Maybe. Probably.
This is why I want San’layn as their own race. I don’t want to see Blizzard go “SHAZAM! Blood Elves have San’layn customization options!” and not have any story to go with it. How did the Horde accept San’layn? Where did they come from? What is their backstory? How are San’layn Paladins a thing? Do we get anything other than Blood Elves LARPing as San’layn?
I guess I’m one of the weird players in that I love world building and storylines, and customization races can work…if effort is put into them. I want playable San’layn, but I’d like to have some love and care put in to add to the world. Not just slapped onto a race with little to no fanfare and no recognition of it in the game.
I could go on and on, but the important point to me is that San’layn would be best as their own race. Lots of storyline possibilities and neat gameplay designs can go with them that I think would go best as their own race. Use the Blood Elve models if you have to in their creation, but let them be their own thing.
Any race that becomes playable should get love and care. It doesn’t have to take a huge amount of resources. Customization races can work, but I want them with their own identity and having a presence in the game. Not just slapped onto an existing race without much thought about it otherwise. It just feels flat otherwise and detracts from the game.
Just my personal opinion, of course.