So I loved the voice acting and music here. I thought it all fit really well. The animation, while fitting and definitely evocative, clearly establishing the thematic vibe, to me–it didn’t seem to flow, as well–as in, the story was more about what was being said, and the art was meant to play counterpoint to it–which the music alludes to well. I think, there, I just wanted more. I don’t know if it would have made things better, though, but I can see how people might find it disappointing in that light compared to the others.
That said, …I really liked this. I liked the visual story that belies the spoken one. I like that we get to see Denathrius as a real villain here, and that we see his own scribe being disgusted by this while his loyal and trusted ones are afforded every anima luxury.
I also REALLY like that Blizzard included a zone like this in the game. Imagine being tortured for “eternity” and when you’re finally broken, being offered the chance to become one of the torturers (a.k.a. the Ven’thyr.) While I doubt that story angle will be capitalized on much in the game, as this is a T for Teen rated game, the fact that it’s still there to be explored by older players, to me, is amazing. And this short definitely sets the mood for those stories to be told.
I especially liked seeing Garrosh unrepentant–defiant, even, and while I didn’t get a good look at his eyes when they showed them (I watched the video twice, and the second time, I was more listening to the voice over than looking at the art,) I felt like there was some clear hatred there. There was a comment over on YouTube where someone said it would be cool if Garrosh became like a vampire hunter type character, and I have to admit–I think that would be pretty cool. I still feel like Garrosh needs to confront his own mistakes and then desire atonement for all the lives he destroyed, but I’d love to see that story happening along with a vampire hunter arc. It just seems like a cool idea. Apart from that, though, I really did get a vibe of hatred from that one scene when we see his eyes, and I think that was really well done. It also leaves me wondering if he’s working with someone else… Is he in league with the Jailer? Is he in league with someone else? I certainly expect him to be opposed to Denathrius and his ven’thyr either way.
Like many others have said, I do see that tie to Elisande and her Court with the arcwine–those stories that are similar, and while some have said it seems lazy to do another re-write of that story here, I like the re-treading of themes here, since I know the story isn’t the same. While Elisande seems to have had good intentions at the start, is that something simliiar to Denathrius, or are there differences there? I believe there are, and it is those differences that I really am looking forward to uncovering–since there is a whole cosmology here in the Shadowlands that alludes to more new lore things!–of which, as you can see, I am very excited about.
I loved that someone caught that the scribe was left-handed in the video. I actually went back and looked at those scenes at the end again just to confirm it. It has no bearing on anything else, but those little details, and the fact that someone noticed them, are very cool. As a writer, and I assume as an artist, it must be really wonderful when little touches like this are noticed when they’re included.
Overall, I felt really uncomfortable when this video started. Those screams, that coloring–it really combined to make me feel “not right.” Juxtapose that with then the lovely quartet music and the refined (if dark) aesthetics of the art combined with the decidedly cultured tone of Denathrius’ voice, and it played beautifully into those two different vibes–uncomfortable and tortuous vs. refined civility. One has to wonder what being tortured, and then becoming a torturer does to ones’ psyche over time. And it leaves us wondering what kind of “person” Denathrius really is, and if things have always been this way but never noticed until there was a drought. Because that’s the vibe I get from having watched this. And I guess his people are finally seeing a side of him they never knew existed until now. Which makes me wonder NOW–was he doing this to his own people before, and did it seem justified then, or is this something new? Because it doesn’t ‘feel’ new–just his peoples’ perceptions of it do.
Anyway…just questions to see if there are answers to when playing through the covenant story line in the game.
All in all, though, the questions this poses, the tone this set, and the overall delivery made this video far better for me than just the sum of its parts. So while I think this was a great lead in to Shadowlands and the story lines of Revendreth, I don’t think, overall, it was that great of a video. But I give it higher marks because to me, it allows for speculation and questions–and I feel like good art should always do that, even if it isn’t, itself, great. It leaves you thinking about it and remembering it, and wondering about it long after you’ve walked away from it.