How unnecessarily obnoxious. I mained feral in DF Season 1, SL Seasons 3 and 4, and mained a mix of mage/rogue/feral going back earlier through BFA. My role on our M+ group lately is battle rez so in figuring out what to play next patch I’ve put a fair amount of time into Ret, DK, and Warlock to be on top of “is there a better battle rezzer for our comp.” I’m not above calling for nerfs on any of them when warranted.
If I was the kind of player who just wanted the other guy nerfed so I could top a meter I’d be calling for DPS nerfs and frankly despite Ret being top overall I think it’s better to let them have their time in the sun. But their defensives are insane, and defensively, they should have more relative parity with other classes.
We saw destruction but moreso survival hunter absolutely busted in M+ for season 3 and somewhat season 4 despite rounds of nerfs. Seems wierd that you’d use that as the example considering it was terrible for the game. But this isn’t a discussion about damage nerfs - Ret damage is top, but it’s not top by an overwhelming amount that requires it to be lowered.
This is like saying “shadowpriests should always be top DPS and completely unkillable because they dont have a real interrupt, a sheep equivalent, an aoe stop, and they walk slow.” You know thats a dumb argument.
The kind of mobility trade off it would take to balance Ret alternating between SoV and DP every 30 seconds would basically involve them permanently RP walking. With double divine donkey Ret has some of the best burst movement out there and with Freedom they’re basically immune to slow.
Meta’s don’t change overnight. Ret representation in keys over 25+ has increased by more than 500% in the past 2 weeks and they’re already running +28’s. They will likely have gone from one of the lowest melee to 4th by the end of this reset. The main hurdle for Ret becoming meta in M+ right now is not that they’re not already better than Enhance / Outlaw / Havoc, it’s that Prot Paladin is already Meta and Holy Paladin was in the running.
Considering Resto Shaman is flying it’s way towards the top as the dominant healer for 28+'s the last two weeks, thats probably going to spell trouble for Enhance, which means there will be an opening for a new meta DPS, and in non-Prot Pally tank groups, Ret is one of the strongest contenders.
Likewise, Meta’s don’t change overnight in Raids either. For your incorrect assertation about Rasz, adjust your Warcraftlogs filter to 1 week.
Again - nothing wrong with being top DPS. That comes and goes and Ret deserves some time at the top. The defensive disparity between Ret and everyone else is the issue.