It feels more like you want to be right over anything else Gilgamesh. People hand you facts about where we are as Ret right now, and you just want to poke holes.
Retribution Paladins have never been number one on the dps charts. We might start out near it at the very beginning of expac, because of burst, but other classes have always scaled better than us even when Haste/Mastery were our two best stats.
As my main Ret at 444 Ilvl. I am still very competitive with the rest of my guildmates in damage, and in particularly with burst. Our one minute damage profile is not only fun, but comes in real handy for alot of the fights in Abberus.
In Keys, if you get the Exodia comp of Aug/priest buffing into you. I’m telling you that is fun AF.
But what I love more than anything is our survivability. IF you know how to rotate your defensives, you almost never hit a spot where you don’t have something you can use. IF you take Sarkerath for example. I SoV at the vary beginning to help out healers at the start of the fight, then I DP when its my turn to soak. I then have SoV back up for when he does is transition into phase 2.
And its rinse and repeat, with this whole time never having to use Bubble, so I have it for OH SH*T moments of if I get unlock and get the soak in phase 2. Nothing like being able to walk out and immune it tos ave my heals a ton of mana.
I enjoy Templar Strikes, but I have a 2nd paladin that I run Crusading strikes on, and that is the build that will scale more, and once you get use to not having to spam Crusader’s strike/Templar strikes. it becomes quite fun. Though I do recommend a Crusading strikes swing timer weakaura so you don’t over lap/waste holy power as much.
All dps want to be top, but I am more than happy if Ret at the Highest end is Middling in damage. Why? because of our survivability. Right now can survive, and still be free to use my utility like BoSac, and not have to wonder did I just F myself over, like we did back in Vault of the Incarnates. My Survivability right now lets me stay in the thick of things, and keep dealing out the damage, where use to you just had to get TF out. I can burst, and my heartiness lets me stay in the fight longer letting my consistent damage be better than it ever has been.
My only wish would to get Exorcism back. I loved that spell back in the day, and when we got it back here in Dragonflight, but I will agree its implementation this Xpac was bit janky. I wouldn’t mind if say it were a choice node in the class tree and you could use it to change Hammer of Wrath to Exorcism, and let it aoe like it did in 10.0.
I mainly wouldn’t mind that because come next tier its going to hurt not having the cleave from Hammers of wrath like we have in Abberus. I didn’t think it would be as meaningful as it turned out to be, but now that i’ve played with it for a while. Its going to hurt losing that lil bit of cleave/aoe when we have to change tier sets.