His house is built on claydo
well, you donât listen to a completely logical argument - that commanding shout is currently at its most powerful at the algalon fight, so the only option is to convince you that you donât know what ur talking about, and that is evidenced by your logs - youâve never touched an algalon.
Thereâs nothing logical about your argument.
The fact remains that the only utility warriors provide (by all accounts I can find) is commanding shout. A buff that objectively loses value as the expansion progresses. You can argue itâs more impactful on Algalon than in Naxx but the fact remains if it is warriorsâ only utility and has been losing its value since Naxx.
and Iâm telling you it has not lost value since naxx, it has gained since ulduar came out, your argument is that commanding shout is better on heigan because on heigan it was a 13% hp buff and on algalon its only 10% lmao.
Youâre sunderâs are extremely important, and you are also very buffy , warriors will be one of the most played class during ICC.
Show me an objective value measure that determines that. Because I see growing healthpools while commanding shout remains static.
I also never mentioned Heigan, you mentioned that.
Iâll refer you back to what you initially said: âin this thread iâve had a guy say that commanding shout was at its most powerful in naxx, which is hilariousâ
Commanding shout was at its most powerful in Naxx in accordance with the % by which the buff increases health relative to healthpools of players. You can argue that commanding shout remains relevant at Algalon and has a part to play, but that doesnât diminish the fact it is objectively weaker than it was in Naxxramas.
If you want to make an argument for the buff being more impactful you should have done that at the time instead of just suggesting my opinion was hilarious.
Youâve done this to yourself, congratulations.
powerful, impactful? you see the bit where you are being semantic? youâve got nothing
I mean Iâd rather be semantic than make no case at all. Which is what you did.
Iâll copy and paste it since your reply was lazy-
" Iâll refer you back to what you initially said: âin this thread iâve had a guy say that commanding shout was at its most powerful in naxx, which is hilariousâ
Commanding shout was at its most powerful in Naxx in accordance with the % by which the buff increases health relative to healthpools of players. You can argue that commanding shout remains relevant at Algalon and has a part to play, but that doesnât diminish the fact it is objectively weaker than it was in Naxxramas."
ok, ill give you an option, you tell me which you are choosing
10% hp for the entire raid on algalon
13% hp for the entire raid on loatheb
choose wisely
I donât need to choose, youâre moving the goalposts.
Is commanding shout more or less powerful now than it was in Naxx?
âin this thread iâve had a guy say that commanding shout was at its most powerful in naxx, which is hilariousâ
You wrote that.
its more powerful now, it has no power at all in naxx, the numerical value is never used, it has an effective number of 0, i know you wonât choose because it will undermine your entire point, we all know and you are continuing to try to dance around it
Wrong, you have absolutely no objective measure to distinguish that.
People on the forum can see right through your non-argument.
Itâll buff for 2255 all expansion, regardless of the healthpool of players that receive it.
ok, you tell me the mechanic in naxx that will 1 shot you if you donât have commanding, but wonât 1 shot you if you do
Itâs irrelevant to the nature of the buff in relation to healthpools.
keep dancin snakey
Keep posting from a warrior alt. Whatâs your main, guessing a druid.
You suggested it was hilarious the idea it was its most powerful in Naxx. It was objectively most powerful in Naxx.
1 Like
my alt is better than your main is what ur sayin? damn you roasting yourself
His alt Warrior eats your main warrior for dinner.
Youâd be begging for damage while he be on the top
Well as long as you admit youâre posting from an alt.
Commanding shout has been losing value since Naxx and warrants review to buffing warriors.
Also I can look at your gear in warcraftlogs you realise. So your extra gear doesnât impress me. Iâve moved to 70th percentile from 5th as I geared up, Iâm perfectly comfortable with my progress after playing 10-80 as prot.
Iâll take that over being unable to understand basic semantics.
Commanding shout will be fire for the whole expansion⌠donât be delusional.
Bane of the lich king will def need it.