I just want to know what makes you qualified to call him bad, that’s all. a simple question. hes clear, cohearant and has great points. to say someone is bad because of their voice is silly, its good content and that’s what matters.
3 Likes
Simple fact is he probably could push a little more air through his pipes. Adjust some settings and add some balls to his tone.
If I thought his video was complete crap I wouldn’t respond at all. It’s a good video. He could try and sound more enthused.
He’s not the first human I have ever heard speak.
Come on. Do I need to define human speaking to you? As I said above… NOT the 1st person I ever heard speaking on this planet.
If you can’t tell a friend or family member is happy or sad by their tone or inflection, you may have some issues.
Come on.
And please l2read, I never said his content was bad, his SPEAKING VOICE sounds like he’s being forced to do the friggin video!
Again, if you can’t tell emotions by vocal tone then I dont know what to tell you.
Morality, in this respect, can be described as a corrective recursion. Analogies include “fight only in defense of self or others” and “only refuse to tolerate intolerance.” One shames those who mistreat others; one does not run down people for acting like themselves.
It is frequently evidence of trolling when a poster attempts to make the corrective measure and the insult into the same thing via clever phrasing.
You know who grates on me? Steven Wright. Also, some of the earlier George Carlin. I can tell it’s hilarious stuff, yet even as I laugh out loud the monotone bothers me. For reasons beyond my understanding, this guy grew on me almost immediately. It did take a full listen, though.
There’s another answer for you, by the way: “Wow, that monotone bothers me. I turned it off after twenty seconds.” Done. You insulted the guy instead.
2 Likes
You should realize Stephen Wright is playing a characterization of a “depressed recluse”. " I put a skylight in my apartment the other day… the upstairs neighbors were pissed"
Delivery.
Context.
Intention.
Platform.
Audience.
Come on.
Yes.
And MadSeasonShow plays a quiet, basement-dwelling nerd type. Apparently, the delivery bothers you. I find it oddly appealing.
2 Likes
Honestly if I thought it was intentional I would have a different take on it. And people have blown my stance way out of proportion.
Ever hear the expression “say it like you mean it!”? I just thought a little more enthusiasm would be nice and invite me to also be enthused about his production.
I’m sure he’s a class act and has a great resume.
idk. I just fail to see the point in coming here to run the guy down for any reason. I could see it if he tried to force his ideas on you and and made insulting comments to those that don’t agree. fact, many like his style of delivery and appreciate the work he does. If you don’t like him, then don’t watch him. In the end coming here to trash a guy that seems very respectful himself only makes you look bad.
3 Likes
But running me down for thinking the guy could sound a tad more chipper, that’s pretty cool, right!
Your initial comment was a little nasty, and Madseason happens to be an extremely popular YouTuber (rightly so, IMO). Then you just wouldn’t let it go.
2 Likes
Some people in the world are rough around the edges.
If he wasn’t a popular You Tuber would that have changed anything?
Still at it, huh? How goes the good fight, my very talented, inexperienced, expert on the “speaking voice”?
Ah, yes, but that’s how you put it when confronted about how you’re actually running Madseason down. The rest of the time?
And when anyone says anything, you might hit them back with this:
But back to Mad:
Okay, I’m getting bored with that. I’ll stop there. Keep fighting the good fight!
2 Likes
Not in my mind. I prefer lower-key content creators, for the most part. I’d hate to read what you say about Frostadamus, for example, whose English isn’t even all that good. (And no, that’s not an invitation for you to critique him. Just don’t.)
3 Likes
None of your attacks on me personally will change his voice in the video which I believe is an unenthusiastic depressing monotone.
But you keep making his video about me. I can take it.
Look, I LOVE LOVE LOVE Bob Ross, the painter, may he rest in peace.
He was a soft spoken ENTHUSIASTIC genius. I’m not looking for Crazy Eddie (google that kids)
And look, I don’t expect and amateur content creator to be a “professional”, I just think, and MAD SAYS IT, he could sound a tad more excited
You.Keep.Making.His.Video.About.YOU.
1 Like
Probably considerably older than you.
Madseason is not bad. You can choose to not like him but the facts are he has more support behind him who actually think his voice is ok and his content is wonderful. Look at his history instead of JUDGING people on voice and outward appearance.
And like Williams and others have said. . Step up if you can do better. For the most part, you are just defending a crappy way of looking at the world.
1 Like
Not that I’m for or against Madseason, as I’ve never deigned to give him any money by watching his uninteresting videos, so I’m not going to take a side here, but… Just because something is popular, doesn’t mean it’s “good”.
33 Post out of 95 total post (over 1/3 if math is hard). For someone declaring themselves a quality type of person you really hit quantity on the head in this thread.
Go outside and take a break, maybe shave your neck too.
3 Likes
That-- wasn’t the implication there. You’ve misread the context of that exchange. You’ll note that I added a parenthetical “rightly so, IMO” after the section you clipped, adding my own value judgment on what was and is neutral statement.
1 Like