As another user pointed out in a different topic,
For those coming back to WoW Classic Era without Clone…one thing you need to understand. If you and your buddies aren’t all coming back, you will likely have to get involved in a GDKP guild.
Currently the game isnt in the same state it once was, and the environment does not foster Server growth or player retention, there is a distinct lack of progression guilds, social guilds or any other type, for the most part the servers are currently dominated by GDKP runs, which provide a direct avenue to gear with no side-streets leading to wider community growth. Not everyone who originally played classic raided naxx finished all their goals or was done with the experience, re-opening Character Cloning will lead to an immediate mass-influx of players; some which will just come to quickly check out the game again, however I would wager many of which will form new guilds and groups which arent focusing on selling gear in GDKP runs and will actually lead to long-tem sustained server growth.
Unfortunately the current state of the game, is this exact reason that the hype currently behind classic wow which has rapidly accumulated will dwindle and die if blizzard doesnt act immediately and effectively,
Re-Enable Character Cloning to Classic-Era people want to return, they want to play the characters they invested countless days weeks and months on, and they are willing and happy to pay for the service.
No rational person believes for a second that the data behind our characters was deleted, given that it would demonstrate an incredible lack of understanding, awareness empathy and business acumen on blizzards part, especially given the fact that the entire struggle behind classic WoW’s development was the lack of server backups early on in the development process. Imagine for a second that the same company then intentionally delete their own data immediately following completion rofl, yeah somehow that seems a little unlikely.
We all know it was a tactic used in order to propegate FOMO, and we seriously dont care, walk back the statement, come up with some excuse like we found back-up data on a thumb-drive in Steve’s basement again, we really dont care. Just give us our characters back and let us play, aside from annoying players that they were deleted and forced transfered in the first place not re-enabling the service is actively discarding free money and frustrating potential returning customers even further.
TL/DR Give us our characters back, we will pay let us play!