It genuinely is just really depressing at this point.
Either the writers are entirely out of touch with their community, or they just don’t care anymore or never learned how to write well. None of those are good options.
There have been some absolutely unconscionable acts committed that we still haven’t gotten resolutions for, but this is just… it’s just actively horrible. I really don’t have other words to express my frustration and disappointment anymore. I’ve lost every last bit of faith in the writers at this point.
It was the same with Sylvanas’ whole narrative back in WC3, which–especially for a female character–was egregious. Forcing victims to suffer the continued abuse of their abusers is levels of awful that are hard to appropriately explain on a platform like this. Sylvanas at least was able to have a sense of agency and pursue justice/vengeance. For us in the MMO, we don’t get that in any sense.
Yes, people will say “it’s just a story”, but the point of story is to drive readers/audiences to connect and react and respond. Some people aren’t here for the story and that’s fine, no shade from me, but for many like me that do care about the narrative, and the world, and the characters, the writers’ decisions these past six years have felt a bit too much like the writers just want to inflict pain rather than telling a nuanced story.
How do they expect to sell the narrative that “the factions have moved past the war” when there hasn’t been any actual focus on making amends? Yes, the Horde is helping at Amirdrassil, but the that’s largely because Fryakk and the primalists pose a threat to AZEROTH as a whole.
There’s been absolutely no evidence in the game, in the story, in any form or fashion, that the Horde has made any efforts to make amends. Just like there hasn’t been any active effort from the Alliance to address the Purge of Dalaran. It all just gets swept under the rug and ignored.
It’s truly worse here though because in no scenario, ever, has the Alliance been written to go out of its way to murder three zones of civilians en-mass and then lounge around in their new home after having burned the last one to the ground.
The imbalance here is just staggeringly painful to stomach.
And worse, given my long years on RP servers, I know there will be Horde players who roll to grief elven RPers at Amirdrassil in character. It 100% will happen, just like it does elsewhere, and Blizzard is effectively enabling them and there’s no way to address it. From an RP perspective, what can you do? Put people on ignore? That defeats the whole purpose of having an immerse, persistent world.
They might as well just close up the RP servers at this point.
I’m genuinely just at a loss.