Hey folks, long time campaigner for High Elves, just resubbed so I can chime in on this news (and also fiddle around in BfA for a bit).
First off, I want to thank the devs for this announcement - IMHO it’s an excellent compromise that adds more options to both how Horde players can represent their Blood Elves, as well as how Alliance players can represent their Void Elves, while also allowing players to represent their characters as High Elves if they so desire. More character appearance options is always a great thing, and these options really do go a hell of a long way towards addressing some long-requested options for both sides - many Blood Elf players, for example, wanted blue-glowing eyes. On the other side, a lot of Void Elf players (and I don’t mean just players who wanted High Elves, but bona fide Void Elf fans) have been asking for more skintones.
Speaking of skintones, the diversity options are well overdue, so its really great to be seeing Elves with diverse skintones and representation. That was well overdue and something I’d been asking for for a long time, so that’s also really cool to see.
So…yeah, overall I’m pretty damn happy with this news, and I’m actually motivated to level up my Void Elf now. So you’re bringing at least one player back to the game with this move.
I do agree with some of the expressed sentiments that some less tentacley Void Elf hair options would be nice, or that disabling the visual (or providing a less voidy version) would also be great too, and since Shadowlands is putting so much work into character creation, I’d like to add my voice to the chorus and say that some more options in those areas would be great (also the Void Elf males seem to be suffering from significant hair loss, is there anything we can do about that? >.>), and I do agree that a less visually obtrusive option for Entropic Embrace would be nice too.
However, all in all, I’m nitpicking - the current changes as is go a long way towards satisfying me, both as a Blood Elf player and as someone who would like to play a High Elf - or at the very least, a less voidy Void Elf.
Look, I agree that this would have been awesome. My concern is that storywise the Silver Covenant will just stop featuring or being a thing, and functionally be replaced by Void Elves. But It’s also important to recognize that the requests for a High Elf Allied Race, and particularly requests for unique meshes, racials, mounts, heritage armor etc. were a response to the point that Blizzard considered High Elves too similar to Blood Elves (and later, Void Elves) to consider making them a thing.
Realistically, Void Elves getting de-bluified skin tones was always going to be the most realistic option, because it’s essentially the path of least resistance. Or the path of least work. Either or.
So while part of me is a bit disappointed that none of the awesome fan art and mock-up skins and meshes we’ve seen over the years will make it into the game, we were all probably kidding ourselves a little in thinking that they would ever become reality anyway. So its probably worth recognizing that as well and, keeping that in mind, being happy with what we have gotten instead. Because, as I said, realistically it was the most likely outcome anyway.