Consecrate will generate more aoe threat than holy shield. Put on righteous fury aura, run in, consecrate, and start attacking. Tell your dps to give you a second before going ham.
Here is how you tank as a paladin. Reroll warrior… That is truth. In this state of the game, warriors where the tank. Blizzard had not really found any kind of tank balance yet. so it is either warrior or GTFO.
I come from FF14 where people communicate a lot and people don’t hesitate to tell you things like “pull more, it’s ok” or “please pull less, can’t heal enough”
In WoW, the experience has been more getting kicked after a screw up, or people just leave. Of course, that’s also retail - is it better currrently in classic?
Not trying to tank at end-game or raids, just trying to go from 40-60.
You don’t have to be a warrior to tank gnom or SM.
I totally plan to heal at 60 as it’s the reason I rolled a paladin.
But I have seriously fallen in love with being able to solo things harder than me while questing. It now goes fast, even if it is still wack . . . wack . . . wack
but when i make a bigger pull on my druid i am a lot more active positionally
i incrementally make bigger pulls early on (with a new group, or even group i’ve run with before) to make sure everyone is on toes
and not big enough that if shtf i cant get my self out of it (and this is how i sort of judge even bigger pulls- could i survive it if shtf and i gotta bail and at least run out and back in to use battle res)
another thing people often overlook is shield spikes. I used to use those cause some friends/guildies would pull threat. Luckily, they knew when to feign, etc but still useful to hold aggro. Also being spacially aware of your consecration so you don’t break sheep on harder pulls etc.
Would highly recommend alchemy as it will make your life easier controlling things like your stats and mana.
I’d recommend making friends with someone to get shield spikes too.
Build I would recommend is 11/31/9:
Go holy until consecration, then go deep into protection to get the holy shield and blessing of sanctuary as those are important. Then beef up with some supplemental stuff in retribution.
You can use “/500501-053050335001051” in the wowhead classic calculator for specifics.