What a stupid take on what I said.
I was just explaining why he was able to hold aggro without an MCP. Nothing about that was shaming for playing outside the meta. Feral Druid as a tank is already outside the meta, so if I were doing that, I wouldn’t even be entertaining someone playing it optimally, let alone playing it suboptimally.
I don’t care how he plays. That crap doesn’t affect me, at all.
Except I wasn’t. Your DPS were almost all green and gray parses with a handful of people 80+ who were attacking adds.
Of course when people give you a 10 second threat lead and don’t hit your target non-stop, you can hold aggro. Actually, you couldn’t even hold aggro, and lost it temporarily to another tank, which sort of EXACTLY proves my point about not being able to compete in threat against Fury/Prot.
If you’re too lazy to farm an MCP, fine, and if your raid group’s DPS is so terrible that you don’t need an MCP, I’m happy for you, but don’t try to pretend the fights where people are not even attacking your target non-stop and give you a literal 10 second threat lead is at all proof that I am wrong when I say you need an MCP to hold aggro against even moderately competent DPS.
I can’t believe you think your argument is valid when your DPS have to wait around doing nothing for so long, AND swap targets periodically, just for you to be able hold aggro.
That argument is exactly like the idiots that think threat isn’t an issue because they can tell their raid to just watch the threat meter and stop DPSing, not realize how heavily you’re gimping your raid by doing so.