Loot council is the worst loot system, you can't change my mind

Gear is a tool to further the raid.

Not lottery winnings.

Wrong. Gear is a reward for continued, long term participation with a guild. Classic raids are easy and donā€™t need optimal gear distribution to progress.

I bet most of you brainwashed individuals who like LC are also in favor of GDKPā€¦ LUL.

someone wanna talk bias? here it is pure and simple a warrior saying no me it is bis for me. but thats just not the case when you look at how the scaling of the weapon reacts when it is in an equally skilled fury ret and unholy dk. the ret will always pull ahead just like the unholy will pull ahead of a fury. literally there isnā€™t anything that it scales great for fury with in the weapon and why? because the shadow damage that the mourne procs is what makes it better for unholy and ret over fury. unholy sub frost basically makes it the perfect weapon for them. secondly that proc from the mourne with a ret guarantees it its smashing faces with how often itā€™ll proc. since they deal bonus damage to undead and demons. sorry but warriors have nothing that makes that weapon scale great for them other than the ridiculous arp on it.

no, heā€™s right.

The raids being easy or not is irrelevant. People want to push for speed runs or optimize for server first kills in the next phase.

If none of this appeals to you, the greedy individual epgp or lottery roll approach would work

It is better for warrior and warrior will do more DPS but that doesnā€™t mean a particular warrior player deserves itā€¦

No heā€™s wrong.

You donā€™t need optimal gear distribution in classic. That is a lie spread by loot council guilds so they can control loot and give it to the people they want. Usually that is the guild leadership, officers, and their friends.

Imagine getting gear to progress in the tier after the raid you have on farm. Imagine that was the reason people keep getting gear.

good thing i donā€™t rely on a mage for advice on a weapon they will never touch. nor should they be the deciding factor on.

he is absolutely correct. the fact you cannot see it is ridiculous. but that is okay. go live with your DKP EPGP or since you probably run those GDKP runs.

Different guilds, different loot systems.

Loot Council works for the truly hardcore guilds (Weā€™re talking world/realm first, speedrunners, etc.), not so much for the non-hardcore guilds.

EPGP is probably the best unbiased system because it is automated, cannot be skewed by human bias, rewards attendance and punishes those who hoard their points.

Bias, like the guy playing a dk saying smourne is second prio to the when it is a minor dps upgrade over their bis DW set up. LOL

People will get gear evenly in an EPGP guild that is properly setup and the guild will progress just fine.

LC is not required. You can stop pretending it is since EPGP guilds cleared all content in every expansion of classic so far.

Even pugs and SR runs have cleared all content.

LUL you have no basis for your claim.

Having loot rules at all isnā€™t required. Having good loot rules in place is to make raids run smoother for everyone.

That is a good point. In EPGP you canā€™t just hoard your points because they will be taken away if you do.

You have to spend them.

hey its true they they are the second best option well unholy is. but iā€™ve VERY clear about how loot should be distributed out. and as much as iā€™d kill for trinkets DBW unholy shouldnā€™t even be with in the first batch of classes to get it. that is a hunter and warrior trinket first, even though that pains me to say because it is a huge upgrade for me. its a better upgrade based on that massive amount of arp.

then why make a post about discussing it lol. wanting an echo chamber?

I wanted to explain to people who think LC is good that it isnā€™t. Mission accomplished.

because the mage is a scorned wife when it comes to loot council and she didnā€™t get loots.

I would never join a loot council guild LUL.

Mission failed. because LC is the best and only option.

Weird how the WOW council member disagrees with you and says EPGP is better for most guilds just like I have said.

:slight_smile: