I posted this as a comment but figured its important enough for more to see.
For those who missed blizzard’s blue posts almost a year ago. I will translate, basically sockets were to much a power increase in PVP, so blizzard added sockets to PVP scaling, and thus intentionally nerfed them.
This happened in September of last year! You can find this in wayback. We were never suppose to gem sockets in PVP after this nerf happened. But people got so excited about Wrathion and forgot this was a PVE thing.
I still find this hilarious that most of the 3k PVPers actually didn’t take the time to study this or read the forums, since many just missed it. I’ve been telling as many gamers as I could about this for over a year. And its not like its been a secret. Blizzard was open about this and told everyone.
And yes, sockets did give to much a power advantage. But its not just sockets that get nerfed in PVP, its ilvl. I have been experimenting with mage in mainly conquest gear and no cloak. I have been 1v2’ing a lot helping friends get their rating.
Blizzard did stuff like this because PVPers complain about gear and mythic level gear being to powerful, so they made gear less relevant in BFA for PVP. Now you guys are complaining that you want your gear’s ilvl to be relevant, which honestly is a contradiction.
Here’s my thoughts. PVP scaling is actually great for lower level players 1-119 players leveling so they can’t get camped by bored 120s. And thus for non 120 players it should stay as it improves the leveling experience.
That being said, it is to confusing for those trying to gear up in PVP at max player level. So thus, PVP scaling should go away for 120 players facing 120 players. However, instead of sockets counting towards gear, they should just be grayed out.
I feel for max level players facing max levels we should just remove PVP scaling since gear is pretty easily obtainable and will be even more so in shadow lands. We don’t have a need for it in rated PVP. But if we really want it, I think Rextoy’s idea of capping the maximum ilvl in PVP each tier to roughly heroic or conquest ilvl gear is actually the easiest solution.
What are your thoughts?
edited for typo’s 8/20 at 8:27PM