Once again, you invent things to put in my mouth to argue against. I didn’t mention inflation, I mentioned how you have to spend gold on consumables for each raid, which acts as a soft decay. Inflation can only make this process hit harder if you only make gold legitimately.
Yes, most people who reject DKP do it because it’s extremely hard to break into when you aren’t there from the start. This is very well known at this point. Are you implying otherwise? You claim you know how DKP works but again you prove you don’t have a good grasp on the flaws.
Dkp is rejected because it isnt transferrable and so everone new starts at a disadvantage. And it doesnt work at all in pugs. Which I explained at least 5 times in this thread, including to you
What are you arguing anymore? I’m advocating that emblems behave like gold. If you agree then we agree with eachother. You asked about a dkp decay, which is not something that exists in gold, quite the opposite. Nobody comes along and takes away your gold when you dont spend it.
if the emblems behave like gold what stops a buyer buying a giant stack of gold, and using that to buy emblems?
and if you mean the emblems should be bop but also able to be bid on items to be automatically redistributed in the group that sounds like the stupidest system ever.
It would enable raids to funnel emblems to a single character so that character can go have loot prio over any other character that hasnt been similarly boosted.
What I’m gonna say is that I’m on the fence with this.
On one hand, I wished Blizzard upheld and enforce 6 months or permanent suspensions to gold buyers and banning the bots more frequently because lets be real, if they were to go hard on gold buyers, GDKPs is fine as it is and wouldn’t need to be banned.
On the other hand… Blizzard as of right now, at least for the higher ups of Blizzard is driven by profits and trying to maximize them, often times people that handle with the bans of the bots and the gold buyers are targets for lay offs and comes with lay offs, its understaffed. They probably dont give a hoot about whats going on in Shadowfang keep, Stockades or Billy getting 500 gold from a level 1 character in SoD.
Honestly I prefer the ladder of banning bots frequently and punishing the gold buyers harder then the slap on the wrists suspensions they have been doing but considering the fact with recent lay offs of their customer support and their customer support being lower priority for years to them, I wouldn’t be surprised that GDKPs were the only option on the chopping block to be banned.
The way you have to mischaracterize every post before you can reply to it isn’t how you form baselines with anyone.
No, once again, I don’t mean like whatever you decide to make up and spout as if I said it. I said exactly what I meant.
How does master looting in one raid give anyone loot prio over people in other raids? How am I supposed to interpret you acting so serious but spouting such nonsense?
A bit of an aside, but I’d also rethink rounding down and consider fractional emblems.
This Is me pointing out that it does not have a decay (which would be deflation) and instead experiences inflation.
Here you are denying that you argued gold experiences inflation and then go on to suggest it experiences simultaneously inflation and decay (deflation). You are clearly confused thinking gold leaving your pocket is decay / deflation. That’s called spending. The gold leaves your pocket but it doesnt leave the economy. Leaving the economy would be decay or deflation.
Oh, really. See above your an example of your two-sided arguments grasping at straws to prove me wrong.
I’ve been pretty clear and concise. See above. But dont worry, im not going to engage with you anymore. I’ve made my points and defended them against you.
I dunno I think he’s doing us a service letting us continue to watch all the copium about GDKP being banned. 5 years is a long time, community has a lot to burn off.
not that you dont know thats a bs comparison, but with your emblem system they can go to ANY PUG after being funneled emblems and get whatever they want. nobody cares if a guild funnels someone, thats their perogative.
a guild should not be able to load someone up and send them out into other players outside the guilds runs with an advantage (like they can with, you guessed it, GDKP)
Guild gives someone all the “easy items” and the go join an SR raid and 5x res a weapon. Thats an advantage.
Also, so what are you suggesting? 39 people spend thier emblems specifically to funnel to 1 person in a raid? Well thats their prerogative and a feature of the loot system. A good one in my view, players choose how to spend thier earned rewards. You can disagree, but that doesnt create a “gotcha” moment like you think it does.
In reality this doesnt happen except in maybe a very rare edge case. Much less often than all the toxic behavior from MS>OS that you ignore conveniently.