At the very least, I want the Old First Mates’ Hat to be a cosmetic item, not Cloth. Same for the old Bloodsail outfit you got from the quest “Dressing the Part” when you hit Exalted with the Bloodsail Corsairs.
At the very most, I want to see these outfits, more importantly the hats featured in this article, as Cosmetic ( not cloth, not leather, not mail, not plate, cosmetic) Pieces, bind on use, for players to collect, and utilize for transmogrification.
How else can I say this plainly, or more clearly? Shove your narrative, and give us the transmog.