In about 100% of instances, what has happened in previous xpacs is fully irrelevant. We don’t play today’s WoW based off of Shadowlands or BFA. or Cataclysm.
Let’s be honest here, A LOT of players are meta sheep. The growth of VDH in Shadowlands was astronomical for keys, given how OP they were in Season 1. (I was there to witness it)
When we look at the top 10,000 players let’s say. Or even 50,000 players. Heck. look at top 200,000 even and see how low Monk representation is. And meta is everything for competitive players.
Out of all MDI regions, that Mists run was the only time we saw ANY monk. And they lost by like 8 minutes in a 9 key. Just tank’s damage output difference is inane. VDH did THREE times more damage in AoE. THREE TIMES MAN. THere is ZERO EXCUSE for that. And these are TOP 0.001% players in WoW.
Paladins have drastically gone after their recent buffs. They went from BrM-tier up to S-tier over night.
There is absolutely no way to sugar coat this.
Also.
Here we go.
DF S1 - There were MORE DH dps than paladins. There were far more hunters and warriors than paladins.
https://raider.io/mythic-plus-rankings/season-df-1/all/world/leaderboards
SL S1 - same thing. Paladins are not in the top.
https://raider.io/mythic-plus-rankings/season-sl-1/all/world/leaderboards
There were same Brews as prot warriors, despite warriors existing since launch
Same goes for BFA. And in BFA, there were 1% more Brews than Bears, despite Bear existing in WoW since day 1.
So your arguement that paladins have higher representation due to fantasy is a load of
My arguement is purely based on a balance.
You’re arguing that paladins are top tanks (along side with warriors) due to fantasy popularity. Yes, people who push past 11’s care so much about fantasy.