Holy crud this thread is long lol.
Anyway, good, needed to happen. I would argue that it needs to be removed completely.
“But Sabbia, why on Earth would you say such a thing!? What about muh loot?!” Well, friendo, let me break it down for you. While the open world is still providing gear, you can kiss any sort of interesting or challenging components to said open world goodbye…or hello since, you know, it isn’t a thing lol.
Why? The open world HAS to be done with the lowest common denominator in mind. I’ll repeat, it HAS to be done with the lowest common denominator in mind. Rewards and subsequent value of said rewards will always be tied to a particular piece of contents difficulty. Nothing is going to change that. I can’t think of a single game on the market that doesn’t run with this concept, and no, FF14 is exactly the same way.
There has never been anything difficult about the open world and that will continue to stay the same. There has been content not tied to the open world, such as visions, which was good in concept, but for some odd reason Blizzard doesn’t seem to enjoy the idea of evergreen content. It’s a concept that could have been built on and improved but they keep abandoning everything lol.
Fact of the matter is, if you actually want a better open world, power based rewards need to be removed. I agree that it needs better content, more varied content, and yes, much more “interesting” content, but so long as there is a subset of the population using it as an actual method of gearing, it will never happen. Until the gear is removed, the best thing you are getting is the usual fill the bar nonsense that people can practically sleep through.
The rewards for the open world need to be cosmetic. Transmog, mounts, pets, titles, etc., they shouldn’t be tied to power. I’m sure there are lots of people that will disagree, and that’s fine, but that’s the reality of the situation, sorry.
Also, delete LFR.