Kul Tirans and Humans are the same race, and yet both are different playable options. The fact that High Elves and Blood Elves are the same biological race is irrelevant.
But Blood Elves are indeed High Elves. The bottom line is both factions can’t have the same race. They said that making Pandaren be able to go either way was a mistake and they wouldn’t make any race neutral again. Horde already has the High Elves, they aren’t going to give them to Alliance too. They gave you Velfs so you could have the same model. And if you think about it Velfs are also High Elves, them absorbing/using the Void doesn’t change that fact.
They are the same race, yes. They’re not the same group of people, though.
They never said such a thing. One Blizzard ex-employee was asked about his opinion on Pandaren and said he personally wasn’t fond of them because of their neutrality. The subjective, personal opinion of an ex-employee does not equal to Blizzard’s official stance on this.
Horde has Blood Elves (High Elves 1), and the Alliance doesn’t need to be given High Elves (High Elves 2) because, here’s the thing, they already are an Alliance race - they’re just not playable.
That’s the problem - we never cared about the model, we want the lore tied to the specific group of Alliance High Elves, something that Void Elves unfortunately don’t offer (because they’re Blood Elves).
People against playable High Elves usually argue Void Elves are a different biological race. In any case, they are not the specific group of Thalassian elves that never left the Alliance, so they’re not High Elves (High Elves 2).
Blood elves ARE High elves, get over it.
Calling yourself a different race doesn’t change what you are, Blood Elves only called themselves that as a homage to their fallen kin, that doesn’t change their biology.