Ask yourself why the multi billion dollar marketing industry also says summer ends on Labor Day. Their commercials and ALL marketing moves to Fall content after Labor Day.
I’m fine with the phased content rollout. But if you think Blizzard can be trusted to remake things from Vanilla from scratch and make it somehow fit, you’ve got another thing coming.
Just revert everything on the patch notes that were nerfs to content and give a global nerf to offset better classes. Both the reversions and nerfs will be progressive, so it will gradually be lessened and then removed once Naxx hits.
It also causes a bunch of issues because of how the balance of 1.12 works with classes. It’s not perfect, and it’s not the next best thing.
Classic WoW was never going to be all that difficult because Vanilla WoW was honestly not all that difficult. Not even in 1.1 before the nerfs and buffs.
At some point, people are going to need to come to terms with the fact that it was always impossible to recapture your personal experience. It’s not 2004, and we can’t unlearn the game.
Private servers were only popular because they were the only Classic available. I can guarantee the folks that wanted Classic will be more than happy to play an accurate Blizzard version over an inaccurate, guesstimated pserver version.
If not, well… then they never wanted a true Classic.
A true Classic would mean using the actual patches instead of 1.12 with gated content. Private servers at least did what they could to emulate earlier patches with things like item changes to previous versions.