This thread got interesting.
Garrosh was loved, unloved and loved again for all the right and wrong reasons.
First he was too nasty, then it looked like he was trying hard to be the leader people wanted and listening to advice, then he lost his mind and went full racist but also full explosive warrior power. The man was a seething sea of confusion.
I think we can all agree everyone was very wtf when Thrall stepped down and made him warchief. That had little logical sense. We got hopeful for a time and admired him but that went flat fast.
He is still admired for his strength, strategy and power as a warrior. If he didn’t fracture the Horde, he very likely would had conquered Kalimdor easily.