I maybe just have a different opinion on what is S tier. Yeah frost mage is S tier against warriors and some other melee, but just doesn’t feel like it’s S tier when close to half the specs in game are just as strong or better.
Good unholy dks, spriests, aff locks, mm hunters, dev evokers, even some really good assassination rogues make me feel well below S lol. Don’t get me wrong, frost mage is strong no matter what, I just don’t think it is a blanket S, but there is definitely some bias no doubt
Most of the specs people are saying are S, I would just put in A-A+. At the end of the day affliction warlock and preservation evoker are the only 2 I would put in S for sure (e.g., S pmuch no matter what). Disc is a contender for always S too, but they don’t seem unpunishable to me.
The rest I would say A+ or S sometimes depending on matchup. To me S is when you are beyond dominant in virtually any/all scenarios, and you can play incredibly and consistently worse than your opponent(s) and still climb rating.
Maybe that definition isn’t a great one, but it’s why I still feel that frost mage is A+ in more matchups than not, and only S against a handful of melee (especially warriors), and a handful of grossly undertuned specs.
Maybe I also queue into way too many affliction warlocks and mm hunters, that could be the case too
In any event, trying to be objective, I do think ice lance is still too powerful in comparison to all of our other buttons. Feels kind of lame to check details and see that a spammable instant cast (which cleaves) is always 25-30% of our damage, and no other damage source coming even remotely close to that.
Mage really didn’t need the extra shield baked into barrier either imo, and alter time is still poorly designed with respect to pvp, since it rapidly fluctuates between practically useless and extremely broken overpowered based on the matchup, with very little in between.
I think the cleave effect on ice lance is also dumb for pvp. It would be nice as an option sometimes, but it more often just makes trying to cc/make cc stick really unfun in a lot of matchups.
On a last note, I want to play my holy paladin lol, but reading forums and personal experience from mage pov has made me not want to bother until another tuning pass lol. I miss the instant queues