Ok…
As I see it, we already got past this point, so why are you re-framing back to that item in a binary way? There are solutions here, we need to stop pretending like there aren’t
–
I’m only going to speak for myself here, and I emphatically agree with this portion of your post. Blizzard has already stated (quote below*) that there are three parallel progression paths; and that individuals (link below**) that focus on one content path should be within 95% power threshold of a full engagement min/max type player. This isn’t reflected in their current game design that massively incentivizes Raiding as the only true competitive progression (compounding throughout the course of the tier) path.
Holla.
–
*Quote