This is a quote from the discussion a few weeks ago you are referring to:
I agree with you that 5k doesn’t go very far when it comes to purchasing things from GDKPs (though you can gear a toon prebis + AQ20 / ZG / lower end MC / BWL gear for 5-10k gold), it will only purchase a single item in higher tier raids.
For example, in the naxx GDKP I’ve been attending weekly for the past months, items start at 10k min bid and the total payout is usually 20-35k (depending on whether I get top healing bonus ) Yet, the payout of an AQ20 or something can be just a few hundred gold. The cost of items in GDKPs is tied to the demand and difficulty of content, easy things have really cheap items and hard raids like naxx (which you need 38+ people with experience in the content, really good gear, lots of consumes, world buffs, and wipes can ruin the lockout for everyone) have really expensive items because there are only a few runs each week that can clear the content.
Here is the link incase you wanna peek at our convo again: GDKP and boosting must be shut down in every version of Classic, or WoW for that matter - #5 by Tubbly-terenas
Cost of items - both inside and outside GKDPs - has gone down slightly in last few weeks since I made that post. So it is a great time to make an alt as you can get a lot of tier gear for minimum bid - but the rare items still go for a decent chunk (though generally a bit cheaper than things were last few months).
You can keep saying that GDKPs aren’t a real raid system, and it is fine to hold whatever opinion you want. But in the game there are thousands of people who raid using that loot system and do not buy gold. They are not getting carried, either. They choose to raid with GDKPs because it is the loot system that gives best gear distribution, incentivizes people to continue raiding full bis toons, and are overall a fun time.