In a broad discussion about dual specs maybe but if you keep it to the game we’re playing and talking about - TBC - then there are some negatives one could fairly posit about their existence in relation to the expansion we are engaged in.
I think dual spec would be a very positive change for this game. However, I think you should be briefly penalized for switching specs in a way that does not hit the bank account.
After switching, you should get something like rez sickness for 2 hours to prevent people from switching specs anytime they run into an unfavorable pvp matchup and to encourage people to main a spec. That would keep the classic spirit alive without forcing people to run around in circles for a black lotus every time they want to change specs.
TBCs devs already explained it to you and Im sure you’ve read the quotes as theyve been posted many times. Specialization isnt supposed to be a carefree option in TBC - its inherent to how it plays.
With dual specs, specialization means that much less and so people who opt to play tanking and healing roles exclusively have their roles undermined by the addition of said mechanic.
I could go on and talk about what added convenience does to immersion and the individuals who play classes that can fulfill multiple roles and the pressure put on them when its now so easy and how raids are trivialized and how its not true to the spirit of TBC and what that amounts to and…
You are conflating his position with a completely different one.
Just because he wants a nostalgia experience doesn’t mean he believes TBC was perfect in everyway and couldn’t use improvements from a desgin standpoint.
I said it man. Right in this thread fairly recently. I am a no changes guy. Im a no changes guy because I know where the Classic games real problems are - the herd that plays it - the games are fine otherwise. Im not afraid of playing au natural. You get the right people playing this thing and all is well in the world as smooth jazz fills the cosmos.
Even so, Im cool with some changes even though Im a no changes guy because I know most of the people around me in game cant be trusted to not ruthlessly degrade the experience and so like a four year old, you have to take the matches away lest they burn the place down. Some intervention is probably necessary for me to enjoy TBC under such circumstances.
Doesn’t matter. It’s a benefit that shouldn’t be allowed to any player in TBC. Half because it wasn’t in original TBC, the other half because the consequences of allowing it are completely unpredictable, which is not the right prescription for a recreation of a classic game.
Not everybody is you In fact I would say you’re very unique most people I know when dual speck was implemented including myself by the way I was excited for the freedom to try something new.
And healing and tanking in wath/tbc Is is completely different than doing it in retail so yeah that’s why Is tanks and you are still good instant cues.