Yea I mean you could make it work. You could give each profession their own groupwide buff. But then you’d also probably have to give the LWers something to compensate if everyone else got something new. and by that point you’re almost designing whole new systems for the game…
Or… you could just add the tinnitus debuff that already exists in later versions of the game and has been proven to be effective while still making LW valuable
The thing that bugs me is that unless you are in a Uber casual guild, drums effectively limits you to one profession choice. I know it’s a “choice” to go LW, but any sound raid leader will look at people and say “ that person has lw, let’s bring them to the raid instead of the person with mining and jc”
Has to be done during the raid. Talking to Jaina or Thrall spawns the gems after bosses 2 and 4, but unstoppable undead spawn behind the raid forcing you forward.