Here is a list of items I think should be toys and justifications for certain categories of items since not everything can be put into one section.
Default: Not much explanaiton here just items I think should be toys.
Anti-Doom Broom
Beeholder Goggles
Butterfly Net
Cooking School Bell
Darkmoon Cannon
Fire-Watcher’s Oath
Flight Master’s Whistle
Log
Prestige Card: The Turn
Pouch of Ebon Rose Petals
Pouch of Red Rose Petals
Secret Fish Goggles
Starlight Beacon
Stuffed Bear
Engineering:
As mentioned wormhole items that are engineer specific are already in the toybox as is the world enlarger/shrinker and Gnomish Gravity Well they just have engineering skill requirement. I propose adding more items to it.
Deepdive Helmet
Jeeves
Rechargeable Reaves Battery
Racial:
The Clan Banner toy is already racial specific for orcs/mag’har so I think the items rewarded from the Gnome & Tauren heritage should be toys as well.
Ancient Tauren Talisman
G.E.A.R Tracking Beacon
Teleporting:
Then there are teleport items that should also be toys. I know teleport toys are not normally the norm but if wormhole from engineering and Fractured Necrolyte is a skull I don’t see why not.
Adept’s Guide to Dimensional Rifting
Admiral’s Compass
Direbrew’s Remote
Jaina’s Locket
The Last Relic of Argus
Lucky Tortollan Shell
Relic of Karabor