No, the fact it can be used against innocent people who actually didn’t break any rules is what makes it an injustice.
Stop strawmanning.
Speaking of strawmen:
I think it’s really telling that people who argue in favor of the automated punishments always assume those against it just want to be able to say things that are actually against the ToS.
Our entire argument is that the system does not actually differentiate between guilty and innocent and equally applies punishments, automatically, to both.
RCR should add the target to your ignore list temporarily, but that’s it. Just because YOU don’t want to hear what someone has to say doesn’t mean no one does, nor does it mean it’s against the rules.
Appealing it doesn’t change the fact it was unfairly, and automatically, applied in the first place.
The squelch is applied regardless of whether they were breaking any rules. That’s the problem.
But we know what kind of person you are: