Thats fair.
From my perspective, I dont see any guilds but the top 1% to have the level of optimization necessary to render a genuinely good memespec player useless. Sure, they’d be better on rogue or warrior, but the fact that they are at 60, geared, ready to go, ready to farm consumes, etc just means SO much.
Even if they’re average in raid DPS, I’d rather have a middle of the pack Shadow or Feral player than a low hanging mage.