Yes. Ideally.
Even Pikaboo himself, our recent NA AWC winner thinks so. Apparently Absterge is of the same mind, if only because he thinks he can outplay people with game sense (being good historically in LAN settings). Not sure about Wizk. He strikes me as pro-addon but that’s speculation.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rgUn-Ik4NS4
There are other prominent names in the arena / AWC scene who agree, but perhaps the people playing and winning at the highest level give the argument some ethos.
Blizzard could simply remove access to certain features in the API. They don’t have to determine what kinds of addons people are using if they don’t provide the tools and information to create said addons in the first place.
Limiting that API all of a sudden, this deep into fan-made addons and with the whole game built around it, is the real issue.
I’m all for it.
But I don’t think it will ever happen because Blizzard will never put in the effort to replace free (and probably better) work done by the community for the benefit of a controlled and equal playing field.
Probably more people will be upset by addons absence than by their presence at this point. At least that’s certainly what Blizzard thinks. Even if there’s the chance removing them will draw in some new players.
As said…
Also, easy content already exists for casual players, and Blizzard are fine with the fact that high level play (PvE and PvP both) require intense amounts of game knowledge, preparation, and configuration. That’s part of the appeal, or at least what keeps people around and interested.
There’s not really a niche for casual high level play. At least from a player retention standpoint. You’re either casual, and fine being disadvantaged, or serious and digging your teeth into every possible database, community or UI driven advantage.
I’d like for it to be different.