While I have been very (and onerously) vocal about my profound disappointment in the decision to put the new Night Elf capitol nowhere near the Night Elf ancestral lands, that is independent of the amazing art and zone design from what I have seen to date. It is a very lovely location, and Blizzard is taking the opportunity to “clean up loose ends” on smaller plot beats (for instance including Night Elf death knights, demon hunters and Shandralar mage NPCs).
My peccadilloes? I am not fond of the name. Darnassus, Suramar? Names like that have a better mouth feel. Bel’ameth sounds like one of those ubiquitous towns you either visit or explore because it doesn’t exist anymore. But like I said, this is a trivial complaint.
Narratively speaking, though, while it may be the new Night Elf home, it will not be home for mine. But this is in keeping with what happened to many soldiers in WWI - where the trauma of war caused a fair amount of “expatriation” and a generation being labeled as “lost.” And while I get the Night Elves, in general, would not have been so shocked, there are individual experiences, and it would be “in character” for my toon to not have her issues resolved, and especially not respond well to being “told” how to believe or feel.
And from a narrative perspective, unless something else changes in the narrative as we wrap up the expansion, having the Night Elves genocided then exiled from their lands and then getting chummy with the people who did it for what could easily be self-serving reasons. The Horde did not defend the World Tree out if the goodness of their hearts - which would have been the case if they had literally nothing to gain (compared with the Alliance helping the Horde reclaim Brill and Undercity, in which the Alliance gained nothing but an NPC’s gratitude and the Night Elves softly got some of their undead kin back, and would not have fared any worse for Brill and Undercity remaining in ruins…um…bigger ruins). If the World Tree fell to Fyrakk, then the Horde would have been equally screwed. The Horde had no choice but to come assist in protecting the World Tree, for their own self-preservation. So there is no satisfying narrative conclusion here, either.
Again, the peaceful resolution between the Night Elves and the Horde was not earned. Not at this time. And I don’t think there ever will be, because the only “earned” resolution I can think of would require the complete re-design and repurpose of one to two zones, if not more - and that isn’t in the works for the next decade.
So it is what it is. I wish I could enjoy Bel’ameth. It really is a beautiful zone and I know that Blizzard’s design teams are going full thrusters. For me it will always be a constant reminder of how Blizzard so thoroughly whiffed the narrative, and reinforces my belief that the only reason Bel’ameth is in the Dragon Isles is because Blizzard wouldn’t or couldn’t devote the resources to put Amirdrassil someplace that had more narrative connectivity to the history of the Night Elves.