Are you a developer of patches for Warcraft or a technical director who is responsible for what changes will be in the next patch?
Most players in wc3 are not pro and they want to play balanced game
Right now the game is not balanced, because in tournament games the undead often defeat people.
What is not correct is trying to analyse balance only from few top players
No, on the contrary, it is on the basis of tournament games that it is correct to calculate the balance and not on the basis of MMR.
Because in tournament games, all the best advantages and disadvantages of all races are revealed and exploited by the players the most. The strengths of one’s own race are most exploited, and the weaknesses of the enemy’s race are most often targeted.
Therefore, the balance needs to be calculated and changed based specifically on tournament games.
Low-level players look at the fact that at the pro level of tournaments, the human race is weaker than the undead, and the undead dominate everyone, so they do not want to move to the pro level. Therefore, the audience of pro players participating in tournaments is almost not growing.
In addition to them, those who have not yet bought the game and are wondering whether it is worth buying it usually want to see what the game is like and what its balance is. They can only do this by watching tournaments on YouTube. At tournaments on YouTube, they see that the undead race dominates over others and wins more often than others, so only those who want to play as the undead buy Warcraft. But there is no desire to play for the other three races because they see that they are weaker, so players who would like to play for other races do not want to buy Warcraft.
For this reason, the Warcraft audience is hardly growing, and for this reason its sales are low.
To increase the number of sales of a game, you need to make the game more popular. To make it more popular, it needs to have an influx of new players who want to reach the pro level and participate in tournaments. And in order to increase the number of such pro-players, it is necessary for players who have not yet bought the game to see that the balance in tournaments between all races is more or less even, and one undead race does not dominate the others, and the alliance is not the weakest race.
But it is impossible to worsen the capabilities of the undead race, otherwise undead players will stop playing for it. This means we need to improve the race of people in the ways that I proposed.
In addition, it is necessary to radically expand the game in terms of the variety of new strategies and tactics in it for the remaining two races of orcs and elves. To do this, you need to add everything that I suggested in the topic about 49 improvements because this will diversify the game as much as possible in terms of new tactics and strategies
And after all or most of this is added, then based on what was added, make adjustments to the quantitative indicators of the figures in the balance sheet. Increase some and decrease some in numbers in order to achieve balance between the races. It will be visible there.
It seems to me that this is the only way to achieve a significant growth in the audience of Warcraft 3 and an increase in its sales. I have experience balancing other computer games, and it tells me that this is the only way to qualitatively improve Warcraft.
To understand all this, you need to have a humanitarian mindset like mine and understand psychology. It seems to me that the developers of patches for Warcraft worked for a very long time with people with a physical and mathematical mindset (technical people), otherwise they would not have made such mistakes in psychology that resulted in the wrong paths for the development of Warcraft.
What I wanted to say is that it’s not obvious that Ud is stronger than Hum in current balance, this is a controversial issue. And I leave it to comunity for further discussions.
This is very easy to check if you conduct a couple of surveys among the game’s audience. For example, collect all the top players who participate in tournaments more often than others and hold a vote among them - are the undead the most powerful race in tournament Warcraft? I think most will answer yes.
The same can be done among Warcraft spectators. I think they will also say yes.
And the same can be done among MMR players; more than half of them will also answer yes.