Ladder win-rates, ladder rankings, aligulac rankings and aligulac win-rates are all in agreement. Aligulac win-rates aren’t an equal skill scenario like the ladder metrics, so they have to be adjusted and when they are they match almost exactly. I went into great detail here:
But, you claim there are different conclusions from different people? That’s a load of horse !@#$. Aligulac, rankedftw, maguro, burnysc2 and my own analyses are all in agreement: Protoss is overpowered. Did you really think that pro level stats would differ from GM stats, when professionals play the vast majority of GM level games? Turn your brain on for crying out loud.
The only way you claim otherwise is to:
A) Utterly destroy your credibility on the subject of statistics.
B) Demonstrate you are incredibly ignorant about the facts of the situation.
My prediction came true it would seem.