Except that most people who play them ARE inconsistent. Ashe isn’t winning matches solely on her own, you don’t just pick Ashe and it’s auto win. You pick her, you do well, and get rewarded. Otherwise her winrate would be in the upper 55%, it’s not.
So you openly admit that Ashe and Widow are head and shoulders above the rest of the cast?
And your proposed solution is for Blizzard to buff the rest of the DPS cast?
I am lost for words.
I’m sorry you don’t understand that going from Open Que to Role Que fundamentally broke the game. But that’s the reality of things
Not sure if I’ve ever seen someone in a greater state of cognitive dissonance. So leave things as they are in a broken status quo with stagnant top dps picks since role queue is the enforced structure? Also, you never even answered the second part of my argument. Ignoring parts that are inconvenient for you? You really think Widow and Ashe require more skill than McCree given their superior mobility? Ashe in particular even has higher, more consistent DPS output.
Not according to the available stats. She’s more likely to win than almost every other hero in every rank from silver to gm.
I never said that 
Yes. Disproportionately more so than other heroes which has caused her to be the undisputed best dps for months.
She currently has 55% winrate in GM. Does that mean by your own definition she’s OP in that rank?
Or did you mean all ranks? In which case the only heroes with that kind of winrate are Sym and Torb. Both extremely niche heroes who are swapped off if it doesn’t work. This is not the case for Ashe who is rarely ever swapped and often plays into mirrors.
Regardless, she still has the 5th highest winrate out of all heroes, across all ranks.
They both fire slower, and lack any kind of stun. Mobility doesn’t do anything but help you escape some fights. They both require you to actually HIT shots to be of any use, if you can’t, their value tanks.
Again, so you can’t understand a game full of overly specialized heroes can’t compete with one who’s flexible.
In OW being good at aiming and having mechanical skill = BAD. And we should handicap and make it difficult for players to perform at their best just because they are good at aiming
People should just miss on purpose so their heroes dont get dumpstered.
And that’s not true for other DPS? WOW! Brilliant! Where’d you pull that from? Like McCree is any more forgiving than those heroes, especially after the RoF nerf.
Yea, and it’s okay that, in a hyper-stylized FPS game with otherwise super-specialized hero roles, incredibly flexible heroes with tremendous kill potential that can excel in just about every meta exist? If that’s not disproportionately high value for a lower risk compared to the rest of the cast and rightfully deserving of nerfs, IDK what is. Look, just admit it. You love Ashe, and you don’t want her nerfed. You’re insanely biased and can never look at things objectively because of your emotional attachment. PERIOD.
Lol Ashe is so easy
Just get HG , spam E and right click and u will get ult in 20 sec because game has no shield.
If you play her 3 games in a row you will adapt to click heads every 2 sec
And if you have Mercym2friend you are literally unkillable and killing all enemy team in 10 sec
What a hard character
Sometimes i play her when im to lazy to think and im winning 80% games on her 
Widow maybe , but anyway she is too OP