Yes we get rewarded more often, but for less points. Formerly we received 25 comp points for a win, now we receive 10. We get bonus points every comp progression bar completed, but it doesn’t make up for it.
Let’s say in a season we play 200 competitive games, with a 50% win rate since over long periods that’s what the matchmaker tends us to.
Under the old system, the 100 wins gives us 2,500 points. Since the average rank is gold, we’ll just use the end of season bonus points for that rank, which is 500. That means for someone who plays consistently and is an average player with a 50% win rate, they’ll usually earn about 3,000 points a season, enough for a golden weapon.
Under the new system, the 100 wins gives us 1,000 points. We also have a competitive progress bar that awards 100 comp points every time it reaches a value of 30 (3 is gained for a win and 1 is gained for a loss). Given the same stats, 100 wins and 100 losses is 400 value on the bar (100 wins x 3 + 100 losses). That completes the bar 13.3 times, giving an additional 1,300 competitive points. And there are no longer end of season bonus competitive points.
So now the same player with the same stats is earning 2,300 competitive points a season instead of 3,000. No matter what number of games you use, the total number of competitive points we gain is significantly lower than before. A 60% decrease in the amount of competitive points we earn for winning a game isn’t made up for the bonus competitive points provided for completing the progress bar. Not to mention the complete removal of bonus competitive points awarded at the end of the season.
The new system was to reward us more consistently, but the same amount overall. Instead, we’re being punished with a system that’s even less rewarding than competitive during early OW2 (we used to earn 15 for a win, then they increased it to 25, and now it’s 10). I don’t mind the new system, and I didn’t expect an increase in the amount of competitive points we earned, but a decrease in the amount of competitive points we earn, especially to this degree, is incredibly disheartening.
The progress bar needs to count wins and losses equally, so that every 10 games you play, you earn 100 competitive points. That would be an amazing fix to this system. It would reward players for simply playing the mode, but still wouldn’t be treating wins and losses equally since winning matches gives competitive points while losing doesn’t. But at least you know your losses aren’t a complete waste of time.