Its not like shes got no utility its more that the utility she does have is not very good.
Her slow is only 15% and only goes up to 30% at 13 with a very short duration for a slow.
Same with her blind, theres really not much special about it compared to other blinds. Blinds are also among the weakest forms of CC. The number of heroes that blind is good against is fairly low and blinds have pretty limited offensive power compared to almost any other CC.
Her cleanse is admittedly pretty good but you give up a talent that boosts the healing of Q by almost 50% at level 7 for it.
Water Dragon is also not bad and its nice to have a way to start fights as a healer.
Shes also got a +10% heal buff and % healing which can be good depending on who you put it on.
Unfortunately, thats kind of where the significant stuff ends. Even including talents.
Im not a huge fan of the stukov comparison as i feel its very apple and oranges but ill bite.
In stukovs base kit alone, he provides;
One of the best slows in the game on a basic ability
A silence
Area denial
The second best disengage in the game with flailing swpie
Or a long knockback that can on occasion, just oneshot somebody
If we include his talents, he also has
A slow that is as powerful as LiLis but stukov can keep a 100% up time on it
2 different ways to make his super slow aoe
10 physical armor that can last forever at 16 and can be popped for a temporary 50 physical armor
A decent root
And another silence at 20
This is why i dont like this comparision. Stukov very much out classes LiLi in utility because that’s what stukov was ment to be. A utility god.
I think we should be comparing LiLi to the likes of Alexstraza, whitemane, Auriel, orthe other healers who are all about tradeing utility for massive throughput.
The reason why i think these are better comparisons is first, its just an easier comparison with all their similarities and second, if the dev team were to turn LiLi in to a utility healer (which for the record, im totaly ok with) they would need to create alot more assets amd rework alot more to do so then it would be for them to just buff her numbers and maybe tweak her target priorities.
Edit:
The other thing im seeing alot is that its ok for LiLi to fall off because shes easy or shes the noob healer. If this is the case tho, shouldn’t we be saying the same for raynor, morales, and muradan? All of which are very much introductory heros. Mura and raynor are both very playable and raynor even has a useful nuche as the guy who buffs camps on big maps or as an immortal racer.
I think its totaly acceptable for LiLi to get her chance to shine somehow. Not just so we can get another healer but as a service for the players who pour so much time in to her.