Arguing over a design change in a bug report forum is going against the very purpose of the forum, and that’s not where you will find the people interested in discussing design changes
And you’ve been informed that it is not a bug, great, that part of the forum has fulfilled its purpose
And the place for that is either the discussion forum or the multiplayer forum
You mean helping players better understand what is a bug and what is not ? how the game has been designed ? Confirming or infirming bug reports by trying to reproduce the cases on my end ? Trying to keep the forum clean so it’s not a mess for people that need assistance ?
Argument 1 :
If you have a 6/6 minion and your opponent casts Helm of Humiliation on it it becomes a 1/1 (now enchanted), if you silence it it becomes a 6/6 back. If you summon a copy of a 6/6 minion with reduced stats to 1/1 (enchanted) and silence it, it becomes a 6/6.
Argument 2 :
If minion A is a copy of minion B, then silenced minion A and silenced minion B are the same minion. If not, minion A was not a copy of minion B
If your opponent is not aware of your presence and you flash, they’ll shoot randomly and have a chance to kill you without ever seeing you. Whereas if you didn’t flash you could have had an opportunity to kill them without them retaliating. In that niche scenario, flashing your opponent reduced your chances of winning. But flashing the opponent, outside of niche scenarios, does not make them stronger.
Just like silencing a minion, outside of niche scenarios, does not make them stronger.
Again, if you want to discuss how to change that behavior, I invite you to post in the dedicated forums. Here you will only find people arguing on the technicality of things. And even when we need to go deep in the technicality, we bring it outside of this forum to make way for other reports, ie the 342-replies-long topic about wheel of death