Ive just played a game against a shamen. He used the minion there summons a 4/4 copy of a minion in your deck. All good there… many can summon from deck. It was Neptun there came with his two talons or what it is.
But then ill silence the minion there came. And when i silence it it went from a 4/4 minion up to its normal stats. That most be a bug or a bad game mechanic. He summons a copy with lower stats, just because ill silence it so it dont have windfury. Do not mean it should get its normal stats back.
It was a copy of a minion. Didnt have any enchantments. So as the minion hits the board in that way. It had never been a 7/7 minion. Never known too those stats. It Shouldnt work like that. Very very bad game mechanics and need change.
And that is why i am making a post. So it can be change. Just because something works in
way now. Do not mean it can not be change. That is why cards get nerf or upped. They get change because it do not work as it should. I should not have to explain something so simple in a Bug post.
And as i see my argument is pretty sound. I makes sense what i am saying.
Not like you saying its just the way it is… that is a poor argument. Imagine taking that view point out in the real world. Then we still would live in caves.
I may come over the board abit harshly. I do not mean to offended. Take care mate.
If you silence a minion with reduced stats, it will grow back to its original stats, that’s what silencing does.
The fact that it is a “4/4 copy” doesn"t change the fact that Neptulon is a 7/7 at base
“Summoning a 4/4 copy” means “summon a copy and enchant it to have stats set at 4/4”. Silencing it then simply turns it back to a copy of the plain version of the minion.
That is the official and intended behavior of the interaction since 2016
I would add, this interaction is well represented in an 8 years old animation of Wronchi where a priest turns a “1/1 copy” of Deathwing into a 12/12 by silencing it https://youtu.be/7-GLkAe_J-4?si=_mG_I6PZyXX1pMRV&t=92
I do not change that is very bad game mechanic. And should change in my eyes.
I not sure if this Bug posting even work. This may be a bad game mechanic and not a bug. But i have posted 3 times now that Hemet the jungle hunter is bugged. And do not tricker sludge or furnace. And it still do not work.
How should i know it wasnt a bug. ???
Come down from your horese buddy.
I though it was a bug at start, so thats why i posted it here.
That it turns out to be a very bad game mechanic. Thats just how it is. I learned that now.
And now when we talk about, maby just maby. Some of the developers looks truth some of thease chats/post once in a while. And it can be changed.
Because you’ve just been told 4 times that it’s not a bug ? ?
-there’s a bug
-that’s intended
-it shouldn’t be
-that’s how it works
-it’s bad
-it’s not a bug
-I want it changed
-that’s how they want it
-I still want it changed
-that’s a change request
-how should I know it’s not a bug ?
Who’s on their high horses ? The ones trying to keep bug reports in the bug report forum, and change requests in the other forums, or the person insisting 5 times that they want an intended game mechanic to be changed under a bug report after being told that’s an intended mechanic ?
No problem with that.
That’s only your opinion
So what’s the problem with my previous message indicating that you are now asking for a design change that should not be addressed in the bug report forum ?
All they’ll see is a single individual reporting an intended game mechanic and being indicated by the community that it’s working as it should. Should that mechanic be changed, there would be a lot more people that would report the change as a bug and/or a bad mechanic.