or you are a liar and you dusted the cards over a year ago
i think your lying
best way to prove me wrong is to open one whispers of the old gods pack and see if the game grants you cthun
your opinion doesn’t matter, If you believe me or don’t, it changes nothing.
I’ll entertain you anyway I guess. I shouldn’t have to spend 100g on a card i already owned, and you don’t know how that code works, if C’thun is uncraftable, it may just check if you own it when you open a pack, if you don’t it gives you one. You can’t dust it so you can’t abuse this. It wouldn’t prove anything, and surely not to anyone that matters.
secondly, I’m not a streamer, just a normal person that plays, how would I retroactively come up with footage? You expect every hearthstone player to be able to do this? Is there some hidden replay function I’m unaware of?
either you have the evidence you need, to post it in the place, that blizzard told you to post in
or you have no evidence and you have to hope they read your post, check your account, and grant you those cards
i bet when they check your account, it will show that you dusted the cards
also fun fact, you dont own anything in this game
your just renting the cards
so why dont you open the pack, see if its granted, and if it isnt, its bugged, and this post is legit
Yes they could, and since I have no proof they are telling the truth, that’s not what I claim, and the opposite should be the same
Since when is calling some one a liar, with no proof of them lying, the normal thing to do ?
The proof for them never disenchanting the card CANNOT exist, it’s ridiculous to ask for it
We are not saying that they are not lying, we are saying that since it’s impossible to know, all we can do is give them the benefit of the doubt and trust that they believe what they are reporting
And for debunking a lot of them, I’m on the side of “it’s not a bug, the player must be misunderstanding or missremembering something, unless we’ve got the evidence or official claim that there is an actual bug”
Why are you assuming that they have a recording of their gameplay, especially showcasing that specific card ?
How would that be a proof that they did not disenchant the card ?
We are protecting an individual that is being harassed for no reason. Not understanding that is concerning.
you seem to be at a loss of logic
so it would be proof they they did?
1 Like
Your inability to understand sentences is a shocker.
Those two sentences are not related.
Maybe you’d know that if you read the sentence in its entirety
unless we’ve got the evidence […] that there is an actual bug
See ?
“That there is an actual bug” is not the same sentence as “That they never disenchanted the card”
1 Like
there is no bug, they dusted the cards
1 Like
You mean, them recording themselves disenchanting a card, would be the proof that they disenchanted the card ? Well yes, that’s what you obtain when you negate the above
Recording random moments of you not disenchanting a card is not the proof that you never did
Recording yourself doing it, is proof that you did at least once
Is that too advanced logic for you ?
Liar, where’s your proof ?
Apparently you can call someone a liar if they claim something they have no proof for. So since you don’t provide proof that they dusted the cards, you’re a liar.
if they show a stream, and in that stream they went through their collection, and in that stream we saw they had the cards
it would mean that the only logical reasoning that that cards are no longer there, is either its bugged, which i doubt
or they dusted them which i am sure they did
1 Like
That logic is so stupid
What’s the point of that recording then ?
“If they didn’t have the card, they never owned it
If they did have the card, they dusted it, since I DOUBT that there is a bug”
it shows they had the card
now they dont
which leaves either bug or dusted
and since there is no known bug
that leaves the only other possible thing, dusted
can you point to a single thread in bug report of someone saying they didnt dust their cards, and blizzard restoring those cards?
1 Like
And what’s the point of knowing that they did have the card ? If that information doesn’t matter in your judgment ?
Bugs are not known until someone reports them 
Have you called liars the players that first said they were missing gift cards before it got officially marked a known issue ?
are you saying its impossible to show images of your collection showing you only have a single copy of a card in your collection?
i would only ask those people to show a image of their collection
1 Like
No I’m asking if you called them liars for only reporting they were missing a card without providing a screenshot
here you go, reread this over and over
as for the missing gift, multiple reports of the exact same thing helps
this is one person with a bug that only effects them
no one else seems to be missing these exact cards
whats more likely, this is a bug that only effects this one person, or they dusted the cards?
1 Like
Using this very thread in example
You did not ask for a replay.
You pointed out that there were no footage, then called them a liar, in the same message, this is not asking, it’s pure accusation
You seem to not understand something that I’ve already stated multiple times
I am not claiming that there’s a bug, quite the opposite
But what’s the most likely ?
That there’s no bug, and that they are wrong ? Or that there’s no bug, and that they are lying ?
you need your eyes checked
maybe is not the same as i am calling you a liar
but now i am saying it, they lied
1 Like
And I am not calling you a big piece of sh*t that is so frustrated in their life that they have nothing better to do than harass players on forums
You’re a liar since you have no proof
no bug
they are wrong
no bug, they are 100% not telling the truth
1 Like
On that part we agree, at least on what we think
Saying something that is wrong, while thinking that it’s true, is not lying though