Nobody is saying Sinful Brand is good design. You’re just not objectively a bad M+ or raid spec.
Awful gameplay, perhaps. Just like Affliction in Legion or Demonology/Destro in this xpac, numbers and gameplay feel are an entirely separate matter.
Again, I’m bored of dealing with people that just links Subcreation charts without even knowing what they mean.
Subcreation means spec POPULARITY on keys. That means that Havocs are doing more keys (and higher rated) and those below.
That DOESN’T MEAN that Havoc is a good spec. It means that in the context of M+, the utility it brings performs better than those that don’t have it.
And we know what utility it is. Chaos Brand.
Any half decent Havoc will tell you the same, Havoc’s current DPS profile is absolute TRASH for anything that is short lived (aka what the whole of M+ is) and that our AoE is totally lacking.
Also LMAO at M+ catering to melee more than casters / ranged DPS. Step into SDepths, do the first pack with 3 packs and tell me how much it caters to melee.
? Havoc is a good spec for timing keys. The popularity reflects that. You can theorize however bad you think the damage profile is. M+ and PvE in general is a group effort, not your personal moment of glory. DH helps teams do keys fairly efficiently. That’s borne by how often it’s used in the format.
Step into any M+, not just SD, without a single melee for interrupts, do large pulls, and get back to me how well your balance druid and shadow priests are covering large packs with 30+ sec cd interrupts and garbage aoe burst and no aoe stuns. I can cherrypick too.