Let’s start with vanilla. A bunch of jumbled, and rather lame stories of the zones, the blackrock stuff-meh, AQ out of nowhere-meh, Naxx-ok, guess it kind of continues WC3.
TBC-Go fight Illidan for…reasons. Lady is draining Outland-no particular reason. It’s safe to say TBC was awful as far story goes.
WotLK- they took one of the coolest villains of all time and made him a joke with daddy issues. They destroyed Arthas. The troll stuf was really good, everything else was awful.
Cata-from start to finish garbage.
MoP- it was actually pretty good with the Lorewalker stuff, but I think most people just felt really detached from it. Zero depth though, Jaina and Garrosh made sudden 180 turns out of nowhere.
WoD- Time traveling Orcs, as if that isn’t enough said. Both starting zone stories were decent at best, and the rest of the zones were pretty god awful. The Arakkoa stuff was okay, a little strange though. Awful dialogue all around.
Legion- Hit and miss. Some of the order halls were really good, others were god awful. None of the zones had any cohesion. We had to collect a bunch of titan relics to close a portal, just for the Legion to steal them back randomly, just to have Illidan open a portal to Argus anyway? Umm…k? The Argus stuff was good, but Sargeras humping the world was a bit off.
BfA- Multiple characters are given depth that has literally never been seen before in WoW. Up until now, it’s just random moments with pretty vague dialogue. You literally had to read between the lines and decide for yourself on so much. The alliance story is worthy of awards imo. The horde story is really good too. Sylvanas is acting exactly how she would if given the mantle of Warchief, I was worried after the Voljin funeral scene where she said “Who among you will help me avenge him” that Blizz was going to ruin Sylvanas, she would suddenly become happy go lucky Warchief.
I can see complaints that maybe the Alliance is putting up with way too much and being too pacified, but with the raid in 8.1 are they really?
The problem is, you and others don’t like the story because it actual tells a story and shows depth. You aren’t used to that. We’re used to lame Saturday morning cartoon worthy scenes with quick cringey dialogue.
I’ll still be waiting for you to explain why you don’t like it, and listen wholeheartedly, besides reasons like “because everyone else said”