Stop trolling already!
Sorry, but your warranty has expired and this call will be forward to the nearest bridge troll in your area.
1 Like
Do I have to flag you for trolling? That’s what I’ll do and there will be consequences.
Consequences will never be the same again!!!
4 Likes
Who’s to say Sylvanas even wants out?
It’s a steady job with a good purpose, it involves exciting action and combat, and she’ll eventually get to do it with the one she loves. It may be her punishment, but the great irony is that it’s likely an afterlife that suits Nathanos’ and Sylvanas’ personalities perfectly. What else could she ask for? Companionship and exciting combat every day, all while fighting the good fight.
She isn’t going to want to leave, and once she finds Nathanos, she probably wouldn’t mind too much if it took a million years to save everyone.
5 Likes
But they already got a happy ending and certainly we’ll have both at the Frontline defending azeroth. So win win.
See I’m not against your heroes have their time to shine or your faction/race too, I just want my heroes and my faction/races to have those things too and sylvanas was done dirt by the devs, is it too much for us to have the bfa cinematic sylvanas? Why only alliance heroes are deemed worthy of happy endings? And horde heroes are even denied self redemption? This is fictional world we sure can have both factions to have nice things.
1 Like
To be fair, at this point Sylvanas is like half an Alliance character, so I guess by those standards we can expect that half of her to get redeemed?
2 Likes
Perhaps you got the wrong impression from my post. I’m not against the Horde. They are my bitter enemies yeah but that hatred only came after Teldrassil. I’m basically Jaina in a Night Elf Druid. I’m a sucker for enemies cooperating and I love a good redemption arc.
I remember being excited about the Legion Cinematic where Sylvanas and Varian fight together against all those demons but then we all know what path Sylvanas took.
Other than that I’ve always loved Cairn and by extension Baine. Lorthemar is a favorite of mine. Thrall I like but I do blame him for all bad that has ever happened to Night Elves since WoW started but I do want to see him get a nice treatment.
I was just saying that about Tyrande and Malfurion because they are simply not allowed to show their real strenght and that pisses me off. I want to see them as how they are in books.
Also with Sylvanas, eventhough I like when we forgive villains this is not how things should be. We were robbed of the opportinity of claiming justice against her for all she did and the worst part is that I can’t even get mad at her now because we conveniently found out she was only her “evil half” all along. Now that her good half is back how can I ask for vengance when she is half innocent?
Now I HAVE to forgive her and we all get there in a not at all organic way.
But yeah, I’ve always preached forgiveness and now I have to eat my anger and actually do it.
Hopefully we won’t have to suffer from bad writing anymore.
4 Likes
She did, in the Forsaken heritage quest. It’s her hope to someday rejoin the faction she founded as just another undead citizen.
3 Likes
Lol.
As if Blizzard would let things like “story” or “lore” get in the way of obsessing over their handful favorite characters. We’re more likely to not see Anduin ever again than Sylvanas.
2 Likes
Look I do get the Sylvanas fatigue but this comes off as incredibly delusional in regards to both the Midnight plot and what Sylvanas said at the end of the Forsaken Heritage lmao
3 Likes
I do sympathize with most of your sentiment but I think that Sylvanas is a special case, I mean she was actively sabotaged by the devs, clearly the original plan was to have sylvanas as the remaining warchief and not be a boggie monster for NE.
Alas we got what we got so having sylvanas atone for her crimes and be a presence for Forsaken and horde players would be good.
As for tyrande and malfurion I do hope the next time we meet the enemy will be so powerful that they will need to unleash nature/elune full might against it.
Thats why it would be cool to have sylvanas leading a token force from the shadowlands to help defend the living world.
As would be cool to have the ma’nari leading a token force from the legion
And Aszhara with the Naga and the aspects with dragons, all against the void. Like I said there is room for everyone and it would be a closure for most old enemies including sylvanas. Helping defend azeroth one last time and having her happy ending with Nathanos.
1 Like
I feel like when she comes back, it’s most likely as a Medivh type figure who comes to warn/advise both factions but isn’t at the front of the action. I think Blizzard is trying to move to a new generation of faction leaders and the old favorites are moving to the background.
That said what we really should be debating is whether “Midnight” is the perfect time to bring Kael’thas back. 
6 Likes
It also comes off as being intentionally obtuse to modern media. Warcraft is especially painfully guilty of bringing characters back from the dead, out of retirement or redoing the same storylines again.
She’ll probably get the Illidan treatment and her return will be part of some grand plan.
Or people just move on. Kael is dead, let our dead stay in the Shadowlands.
Fermian Argument
Sylvanas doesn’t want anything
She is a character written by Blizzard
1 Like
That’s … not as reassuring as you seem to think. 
Which expansion Jaina are we talking about?
On a slightly more serious note, I’m kind of astonished that you can still see her as enough of a coherent/realistic character to have this kind of visceral reaction. She has ceased to be real to me—she’s just a set of pixels that has clearly been yanked in a dozen different directions according to a behind-the-scenes writing tussle. Maybe if you can get past the (entirely understandable) feeling of injury caused by the stupid Teldrassil storyline, you’ll see it that way too?
3 Likes
Dum-dum Informal Logic Fallacy #6783
Games aren’t real, and all discussion of fictional media is dumb.
I am correct, because the fallacies of the Informal Logic definitely aren’t just random assertions based on nothing, and definitely aren’t just cruise-control for bad arguments that I don’t have to justify.
3 Likes
You’re incorrect even if we stick to strictly in-lore elements given that Sylvanas explicitly said she wants out so 
7 Likes
And with any luck she doesn’t get what she wants. Consider it another punishment for her not to see whatever the Forsaken turn into. Good or bad.