no, and if so its because the fights are so short… We literally are not always #1 past 120 seconds…
This is the issue, People dont know how unholy works, or clearly dps… Obviously the shorter the fight the higher the dps, but unholy cant maintain 15k dps tho we can easily burst it. Burst @ 60 seconds literally doesnt matter other than pushing a phase faster (yogg brain), which not stacking dk’s people can do. Dk’s just make it more doable, same as retail stacking for RWF or retail not bringing class because xyz.
on top of that, naxx provides perfect conditions i.e no mechanics, or they are just zug zug mechanics, no boss damage, low boss hp, no hard target swaps (where you would use CD’s) etc… Thus yes sitting there zerging bosses is going to result in the highest burst class out performing everyone.
Move on to ulduar, warlocks were constantly with or above dk’s on every single fight… And the heart on XT with 5 dk’s was barely met and we were all doing 20+k to it. Hell even mages, rogues and moonkins could keep up or beat. Why? because no perfect conditions and longer fights. even 50% haste SS on hodir (yes the gargoyle was massive) wasnt even close to arc mages and warlocks or even shadow priests.
Moving on to ToC we literally prioritize less gargoyle haste, which is why this change doesn’t really matter, but is annoying because its so premature and or really late. i’d say its premature since they havent even seen it perform in ulduar in its current state.
go into the last tier, Fire mage tier set is busted, warrior tier set is busted, rogue tier is really good, on top of all the ArRP that rogue and warrior get, not to mention raw spellpower casters are getting. And here we are, Rets tier set is absolutely insane.
Dk’s would get caught up to regardless if gargoyle got nerfed, and tbh its being cucked prematurely, since .5% of the player base is doing everything in their power to do the most dps for a sub 90 second fight… and no one knows why dk even does damage, they literally think oh its just gary…
gary does like 2.5-4k dps depending on fight length from 36 seconds to 90 seconds… Read that again… and again… move on to to ulduar… the only close condition is what, hodir(which most other classes were beating with equal rng), kologarn, iron council (which warlocks were taking the lead pretty well since giga corruption buffed @ 100% uptime)?
Whats the next example yogg brain? last phase yogg? thats the point of either an execute class or a high burst CD class… literally exists in every iteration of wow.
what about algalon needing 10 palas since their CD is so OP… how bout we nerf divine sac? since thats being stacked too… the logic is stupid… people are going to stack whats best regardless of changes… And blizzard just said “ohh, its over represented in the top .5% and we dont like that” thats not a reason…
Show me the evidence behind gary working that way in 2010 and ill be with you 100% but rn the principle behind the change is stupid.