Why do people not like Sylvanas?

And the amazing part is that people read those ratings and play the game any way. Instead of being morally outraged that the game exists and refusing to buy it or play it, they plunk down good ol’ hard currency, play it, and then express their moral outrage in the game and on the game’s forums.

Not only that, some even let their kids play it, knowing that it’s not rated for the kiddies, then blast the developers for creating the content that their kids aren’t even supposed to be playing. Just look at all the threads complaining about armorkinis, and Sylvanas’ belly button that used to be visible. By the same people who wear two-piece swimsuits at the beach with more than just their belly buttons on display.

I think it’s hilarious. Kinda like the preacher warning the congregation about carnal thoughts and lust of the flesh … then pounding a hooker in a local motel two hours after the sermon. Absolutely hilarious.

1 Like

Actors play villains all the time, actors by and large are nothing like the characters they play, and most reasonably people understand this distinction, and can separate actor from character.

Whats disturbing is that some seem to attribute a in-game character to a real world persona. Who is the one with a real issue ? A persona role playing a character in a fantasy game, or someone who believes the role played character is actually a true representation a real person’s morals and beliefs.

1 Like

Do not put much stock in game rating from the states. it regulated by the gaming companies. Which I find interesting. With some of the stuff they been doing. It should of went up. How it not was answered when I went and look. Now before kids play a game. I look for myself. Don’t mind certain things for certain children. Wow one of them cause I can somewhat control what the see.

I don’t hate her at all. I think she’s a fun villain. What I don’t like is how people can’t admit she is clearly a villain, at least at the current moment in the story. She may be going through an arc and redeem herself in the end, but absolutely a villain right now.

1 Like

In that vein, how is any warmongering expansionist power fundamentally different from the Lich King? Aside from their army being undead.

Yeah, you got that right. According to their logic, John Wick and John Wick 2 should have been monumental flops, right? And how about the old Oceans … series of movies (crooks stealing from crooks). Westworld, according to them, should have been XXX rated if it was even allowed to be produced.

I believe that’s called “situational ethics,” if there are any ethics involved at all.

Hes right , there is no such thing as absolute good and evil. What is considered good and evil largely depends on your culture and the time period in which you live. What is considered good and evil is always changing as time marches on.

I like her.

1 Like

She also nuked my favorite city. She betrayed her own people, she’s clearly only out for herself.

I used to follow the dark lady, and after her actions I cannot. In the mindset of Surafang, we are now fighting without honor.

I shall be patiently waiting for Thrall to return and be that like, Pizza delivery guy gif, then make another new horde because he didn’t intend it to go this way when he left I’m betting.

1 Like

Lion kills gazelle, lion thinks its good, gazelle thinks its bad. Which one is correct ?

Yes it is ambiguous, the word genocide is less than a hundred years old. If you and your people benefited from something that could dubiously be considered genocide then yes it was good. If you and your people suffered from what might be considered genocide then it would be considered bad.

Well, speaking only for myself, i do not dislike her per se, i simply do not trust her.
The Horde overall has NEVER been her priority. Her agenda starts and stops with the forsaken, always has, always will.
And this was all before her more recent actions.

How is it you managed to quote my post, and yet you apparently for some reason chose not to actually read it before wording and posting a reply to it? And if you did read it, you certainly didn’t ponder it with any modicum of critical thinking for the scarce few seconds necessary to comprehend it.

I don’t write in mystical words but very plainly and lucidly; I’m not difficult to understand.

Try again.

1 Like

Indeed, it’s just that your message itself is lacking. Disagreeing with your asinine posts =/= not understanding them.

The fact that she raises them back to undeath against their will. Sylvanas herself begged Arthas for a clean death during the Fall of Silvermoon, and he refused due to her valiant efforts that frustrated him. That’s why she was turned into a Banshee.

Sylvanas: “Finish it! I deserve…a clean death.”
Arthas: “After all you’ve put me through, woman, the last thing I’ll give you is the peace of death.”
Sylvanas: “No! You wouldn’t dare!”

Even when she faced Arthas in Lordaeron when his power was waning, she brought it up.

“A quick death…like the one you gave me? No. You’re going to suffer as I did. Thanks to my arrow, you can’t even run. Give my regards to hell, you son of a b****.” (Gotta love having to censor their own quote from WC3)

“Arthas murdered my people and turned me into this…monstrosity.”
“What are we if not slaves to this torment?”

If you read the Rise of the Storm novel, one of the reasons why Sylvanas snaps and kills the Forsaken who are trying to reconnect with their families is she was so enraged that they could feel happiness, and not embrace that death was the final answer.

She’s evil, dude. No sugar coating it.

2 Likes

Just bad writing. The people behind this writing are truly on the next level of suckage. I mean they can’t even write the whole Warchief isn’t liked by people stick any differently than when they did it before.

Hell hath no fury like a woman scorned, I LOVE her, you go girl!!!

Just about any army kills their enemies against their will.

You literally do not even understand what you’re talking about. You merely read my post and, with having emphatically zero idea what’s going on, viewed it as an opportunity to troll me.

I thought I made it clear to you before that I do not wish to engage with you further. Until such time as an ignore feature is implemented so I can delightfully make you disappear once and for all, kindly stop harassing me.

You merely say that, it isn’t actually the case however. I understand what you’re saying. I simply do not agree with it and find your perspective exceedingly narrow minded.

By all means, leave or ignore me. This is a public forum and I have every right to post here.

Your post is not misunderstood by anyone, as others have pointed out.

You did not like or understand how the OP has a different view/stance than yourself, as a result you attack his mental competence/health.

You used moral absolutism as said basis for attacking OP mental state. Since their is no such thing as absolute right or wrong the OP’s mental heath cannot be actually ascertained in this manner.