For anyone who is seeking to exorcize their internalized guilt about whatever by “saving” the kobolds, nerubians, eredari, orcs, trolls, whatever, then please tell me why the horde has a questline to genocide all the human farmers of Hillsbrad to develop a new plague?
My original post was trying to highlight an overall problem with the writing in this franchise using a couple of examples that stood out to me in particular. Dragons used to be cool in warcraft, until they were made into a family or something. The old gods were semi-interesting lovecraft copies, but after killing the fifth one, the lovecraftian mystery/creepiness is completely lost.
I think back to my first encounter with a Blizzard game: it was warcraft 2 on my friend’s PC (because I didn’t have one at the time) and I was completely blown away by the fact you could play as the bad guys. And make no mistake, the orcs were the bad guys. They were demonically inspired monsters who came through a portal and were given orders to wipe out all the humans. The voice over for every orc mission was basically “THE WARCHIEF WANTS YOU TO EXTERMINATE ALL THE HUMANS IN {insert area here}! DO NOT FAIL HIM OR YOU WILL BE KILLED!”
Fast forward to warcraft 3 and even early WoW, there was more complexity in the lore, sure, but it still felt like the story had impact. The horde and alliance were still quite differentiated in terms of their motivations and their traditions. The alliance was trying to establish/maintain their dominant position in the world, while the horde was still “taming” Kalimdor and securing their place in the world. Modern WoW is just so watered down and bland, there might as well not exist a horde or alliance.
And no, I don’t care what Tolkien did with his universe, I don’t care about wizards of the coast. I’m talking about the warcraft universe, by Blizzard. The writing is garbage, to be honest, and the more they try to write their way out of this mess, the worse it all becomes. Maybe they should just end the world, and do a time lapse 10 million years into the future for the next expansion/saga.
Thanks for listening to my TED rant