Seems I can’t open the box at the moment because “NOW’S NOT THE TIME TO USE THAT!” -Professor Oak
This tends to happen if you already have one of the seeds for the lasher or chum for the eels. Try deleting your chum/seed and then try opening the box.
1 Like
Most likely because of you already having one of the items in your inventory already: Can’t Open Waterlogged Toolbox
Huh, you’d be correct!