I managed to get Illidan to cough up the MH warglaive but it didn’t add to the collection. I know that druids can’t equip them but that hasn’t been an issue with other equipment. Even convinced KJ to hand over the bow and it added just fine despite the fact that druids can’t equip bows. Honestly just thinking about a bear with a bow is hilarious to me.
Using All the Things addon and the tooltip states, “This may require a Force Refresh (SHIFT click) to properly be collected” but even that doesn’t work. Not really sure what else to do. It’s hardly a big deal in the grand scheme of things but being able to resolve my confusion on why this situation seems specific to this particular item would be nice.